McDonald’s food is certainly not the healthiest, but their sauces are truly delicious!
The breakfast sauce, a top favorite sauce of many McDonald’s lovers, has sadly been discontinued — and McDonald’s isn’t planning to ever offer it again. So, the only thing left to do is to make it yourself!
How do you make McDonald’s breakfast sauce at home? McDonald’s breakfast sauce is a combination of a few ingredients, including mayonnaise, mustard, steak sauce, and lemon juice. Use all ingredients in the right amount and you will get a breakfast sauce that tastes just like the one from McDonald’s!
In this article, you will not only learn how to make this breakfast sauce thanks to our very own copycat recipe — you’ll also how to use it, how to make it healthier, ways to change up the recipe, and what foods to pair it with!
What Does McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce Taste Like?
McDonald’s breakfast sauce has a unique flavor. This sauce has a balanced savory flavor with moderate sweetness and tanginess and only a hint of spiciness.
It also has a soft, creamy texture that is one of the reasons many people love this sauce.
Can You Make McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce At Home?
You may think that this delicious breakfast sauce by McDonald’s contains some secret ingredients that make it taste so good — but in reality, you can make a breakfast sauce at home that tastes just like the one from McDonald’s!
Making McDonald’s breakfast sauce at home is a great idea. You can enjoy it not only for breakfast, but for any meal of the day, plus add it to your favorite dishes.
You can adjust the seasoning to your taste and alter the recipe by skipping any ingredients you don’t like and adding more ingredients to customize the flavor.
Additionally, the good thing about homemade sauces is that you know what exactly goes into the sauce and you control the quality of each ingredient!
Copycat McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce Recipe
Now that McDonald’s breakfast sauce is discontinued and you can no longer get it at McDonald’s, the best thing to do is to make the homemade version of this sauce.
Dedicated McDonald’s breakfast sauce lovers have uncovered the ingredients behind the unique flavor of this sauce.
Continue reading to learn what you need and how to make the best-tasting homemade McDonald’s breakfast sauce!
What You’ll Need
As mentioned above, McDonald’s breakfast sauce is a combination of a few simple ingredients. You most likely have them in your kitchen at all times and use them separately to enhance the flavor of your meals!
Here’s everything you will need to make a cup of McDonald’s breakfast sauce:
- 8 tbsp mayonnaise
- 2 tbsp yellow mustard
- 1 tsp steak sauce
- 1 tsp lemon juice
- 1 tsp dried dill weed
- Salt (to taste)
- Ground black pepper (to taste)
As you can tell, the base of this sauce is mayonnaise — even if you don’t like mayonnaise-based sauces, we still recommend you give this one a try!
The combination of the above-mentioned ingredients with mayonnaise in the right amounts results in a delightful sauce that goes well with so many dishes.
The mayonnaise provides a creamy base for the sauce while the mustard adds tanginess. Lemon juice, on the other hand, brightens up the flavor of the sauce and adds some zestiness to it.
Steak sauce is the ingredient we recommend you never skip when trying to replicate McDonald’s breakfast sauce.
Steak sauce contains such ingredients as tomatoes, vinegar, raisins, various spices, and sometimes anchovies. This sauce has a complex flavor profile and adds a lot of interesting flavors to the breakfast sauce.
Dried dill provides herbal notes, while salt and pepper balance all the flavors.
So, if you want to make McDonald’s breakfast sauce at home, we recommend you don’t skip any of the above ingredients to get the exact same flavor as the authentic McDonald’s sauce!
How To Make McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce
Here is how you make McDonald’s breakfast sauce:
- Add all the above ingredients (except the salt and pepper) into a bowl.
- Mix until you achieve a smooth and creamy concoction — using a whisk will allow you to do this in a second.
- Try the sauce, then add salt and pepper to taste.
- Transfer the sauce into an airtight container or jar.
- It is a good idea to allow the sauce to sit in the fridge for a couple of hours before you use it — this allows all flavors to come together!
3 Ways To Change Up McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce
McDonald’s breakfast sauce is very easy to make and you can enjoy it with anything you like. But even if you are a big fan of this sauce, you may still want to switch things up every now and then.
Here are three easy ways to change up this popular fast-food sauce!
1. Add Hot Sauce
If you don’t mind a little spicy kick in your food, then you should certainly try adding a little hot sauce into the homemade McDonald’s breakfast sauce.
If you don’t want the sauce to be hot but still need that moderately spicy flavor, add a dash of cayenne pepper into the sauce.
2. Use Dijon Mustard Instead Of Yellow Mustard
You can use Dijon mustard instead of yellow mustard to make McDonald’s breakfast sauce.
Dijon mustard is creamier than yellow mustard, but it is also a little spicier. You might want to avoid using Dijon mustard with a grainy texture as it may interfere with the overall creaminess of the sauce.
3. Add Onion And Garlic
You can add onion and garlic to McDonald’s breakfast sauce to change up its flavor — the only thing is that not everyone likes to have these ingredients in their breakfast.
How To Store McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce
Leftover McDonald’s breakfast sauce should be stored in an airtight container or jar. As the sauce is made with mayonnaise, you should store it in the fridge.
If you have made a very big batch of McDonald’s breakfast sauce, consider freezing it. Portion the sauce, transfer it into zip-top bags, and store the sauce in the freezer until you are ready to use it.
The sauce may have a slightly different texture when you thaw it. But the good thing is that you will have several months to use the sauce stored in the freezer.
How Long Does McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce Last?
McDonald’s breakfast sauce can last up to 14 days in the fridge. However, a lot depends on the freshness of the ingredients.
If the mayonnaise you are using will expire in a week, you should use up the sauce you have made with it within the week too.
To make the sauce last longer and prevent cross-contamination, don’t dip your food directly into the jar of sauce, and don’t dunk a dirty spoon into it.
Is Homemade McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce Healthy?
We’re going to be honest — McDonald’s breakfast sauce is not the healthiest, even if it’s homemade.
Having mayonnaise as its base ingredient, you can expect this sauce to be high in saturated fats and cholesterol. The steak sauce used to make McDonald’s breakfast sauce is also high in saturated fats and sodium.
Additionally, any store-bought mayonnaise, mustard, and steak sauce used in the recipe may contain a lot of artificial ingredients, GMOs, and preservatives.
To make McDonald’s breakfast sauce healthier, we recommend you buy the healthier versions of its main ingredients, such as fat-free mayonnaise, low-sodium steak sauce, etc.
This being said, 1 serving of mayonnaise and mayonnaise-based sauces is 1 or 2 tablespoons.
So, if you love the flavor of this sauce that has been sadly discontinued by McDonald’s, go ahead and make it at home — just use it in moderation!
Can You Make McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce With Homemade Mayonnaise?
There is no reason why you can’t use homemade mayonnaise to make McDonald’s breakfast sauce. Moreover, using homemade mayonnaise is a great way to make the sauce healthier.
Making mayonnaise at home is easy and quick and you need only a couple of simple ingredients, including an egg, vinegar, lemon juice, and salt. Depending on the recipe, you may also need mustard, spices and herbs, oil, etc.
Fresh homemade mayonnaise lasts only about 4 days in the fridge. Keep this in mind when using it to make McDonald’s breakfast sauce!
The Best Breakfast Dishes To Serve With McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce
If you love McDonald’s breakfast sauce, you will most likely eat it at any time of the day. But if breakfast is what you want to use this sauce for, here are the best breakfast dishes to go with your homemade McDonald’s sauce!
1. Egg Sandwiches
McDonald’s breakfast sauce is an amazing addition to any breakfast sandwich with eggs. Being creamy and rich, this sauce will not only add a silky texture to the sandwich but will also enrich its taste with layers of flavor!
Whether the eggs in your sandwich are poached, scrambled, hard-boiled, or fried, add McDonald’s breakfast sauce to take the sandwich to another level.
If you have overcooked the eggs, dice or shred them. Mix the eggs with a dollop of McDonald’s breakfast sauce and you will have the creamiest egg salad to make sandwiches!
If you are the type of person who loves having sausages for breakfast, then you should certainly try eating them with McDonald’s breakfast sauce.
This sauce will be good not only for regular sausages, but also for sausage balls and vegetarian sausages!
3. Savory Breakfast Bowls
You may not always have time to put together a savory breakfast bowl, but when you do, we recommend you add some of your homemade McDonald’s breakfast sauce to it!
Red potatoes, eggs, avocado, bacon, sausages, and various patties — all these ingredients will pair nicely with this mayonnaise-based sauce and make a filling bowl that will provide you with energy for the entire day.
4. Savory Waffles
Another great breakfast dish to pair with McDonald’s breakfast sauce is savory waffles!
You can make savory waffles with anything you like, including bacon, cheese, spinach, and sweet potatoes. McDonald’s breakfast sauce will pair well with almost any savory waffles recipe.
The Best Non-Breakfast Dishes To Serve With McDonald’s Breakfast Sauce
McDonald’s breakfast sauce is quite versatile — you can have it not only for breakfast, but for lunch and dinner, too! There are tons of exciting ways to use McDonald’s breakfast sauce.
Here are some other foods that we think pair well with this sauce!
If you have made a big batch of McDonald’s breakfast sauce and don’t know how to use it up, make fries. You can serve this sauce with your favorite type of fries – regular, crinkle cut, waffle, etc.
If fries are too unhealthy for your liking, cut potatoes into wedges, bake them in the oven, and enjoy them with this homemade mayonnaise mustard dip.
2. Chicken Nuggets
Another great way to serve McDonald’s breakfast sauce is with chicken nuggets. Ketchup is certainly good for chicken nuggets. But it can easily get boring to eat nuggets with ketchup repeatedly.
So, whenever you make McDonald’s breakfast sauce at home, try it with chicken nuggets too. You’ll love this combination!
No burger is complete without a sauce — sauces help all the flavors in a burger to come together and help it stay juicy!
If you happen to have McDonald’s breakfast sauce at home, we recommend you try adding it to your burger. This creamy sauce with a unique savory flavor will pair nicely with any burger topping.
4. Fried Fish
McDonald’s breakfast sauce can be an amazing addition to fish and chips. Not only the flavor of this sauce will pair well with fish but the creamy texture will also nicely contrast the crispy texture of fried fish.
If you don’t want to pair the high fat mayonnaise sauce with fried fish, oven-bake the fish strips for a lighter version of this dinner option.
While the name implies that this sauce is good for breakfast, McDonald’s breakfast sauce is also a great condiment to serve with steaks!
Another great way to use this sauce for steak is to marinate the meat in it.
Marinating steak with mayonnaise is a common practice since it sticks well to the meat. It enhances its flavor and also helps you achieve a beautiful brown color when you cook the meat!
If all the options you have read by now seem boring to you, then we recommend you make some taquitos to go with your homemade McDonald’s breakfast sauce.
Taquitos, also called rolled tacos, are rolled-up tortillas — the fillings of taquitos can be anything you like, including beef, chicken, cheese, and various veggies.
The rolled shape of taquitos makes them perfect for dunking into McDonald’s breakfast sauce!
7. Crab Cakes
Mustard-mayonnaise sauces and crab cakes are a popular combination. Since it has a mayonnaise base with mustard as one of its main ingredients, McDonald’s breakfast sauce is a good sauce option for crab cakes.
8. Fresh Vegetables
There are healthy options for using McDonald’s breakfast sauce too.
Serve this sauce with your favorite vegetables as an appetizer. You can use cucumber and carrots strips, celery stalks, baked cauliflower, and broccoli florets, or any other veggies you’re craving!
What can be better for a chips and dips platter for a movie night? Serve your homemade McDonald’s breakfast sauce with your favorite chips. Your friends will surely love the sauce they can no longer get at McDonald’s.
You can also serve homemade baked tortilla chips with the sauce as a healthier alternative.