Can You Reheat Carbonara?

Carbonara is undoubtedly one of the most popular pasta dishes around. Its creamy, almost milky sauce gives it a distinctive flavor that easily sets it apart from other pasta recipes.

It is quickly becoming a staple for many date nights. But even after your romantic dinner has ended, it would be a real shame to let your leftovers go to waste. That’s why more and more people are finding themselves asking the question:

Can you reheat carbonara? Yes, you can reheat carbonara, whether you are trying to heat the sauce and noodles separately or together. The best methods to use are the stovetop for the best tasting results or the microwave for the quickest results.

However, there is a right way to go about each process.

Luckily, this reheating guide is here to help you through whichever scenario you might find yourself in. So, be sure to keep reading!

Reheating Carbonara Sauce and Pasta Separately

If you had the foresight to keep your carbonara sauce separate from the pasta, then you’re in luck. This is highly recommended if you are cooking a big batch and won’t be able to finish everything in one sitting.

By storing them in separate containers, you can give yourself an additional level of flexibility in terms of how you want to approach reheating.

This is because the process of reheating carbonara is significantly easier in this case. All you need to do is simply heat the sauce and pasta independently. Presented below are the different ways you can do just that.

1. Stovetop Method

One of the best ways you can reheat carbonara is by using the same method you would use to cook it. This method keeps your noodles soft and your sauce creamy, but can overcook your pasta if you’re not careful.

Follow these steps to reheat carbonara pasta and sauce in the microwave:

1. Fill a large pot with water and turn on the heat. Let the water boil on the stovetop.
2. Place your cold leftover pasta into a colander.
3. Reheat your leftover pasta by placing the colander in the pot full of boiling water. Be careful not to leave it for longer than 30 seconds. Remember, you have already cooked the pasta, so it is best not to overdo it. Otherwise, you risk letting your pasta break down into a mushy mess.
4. Once the noodles are hot enough for your liking, remove the colander and strain the moisture out.
5. Place your sauce in a separate pan and put it over medium heat. Keep stirring until is warmed all the way through.

Once you have followed these steps, you can proceed to combine the two as needed. This method will produce the most delicious results and leave your carbonara tasting fresh again.

2. Microwave Method

Now, if you are in a rush or don’t have access to your stovetop, you can rest easy knowing that you can still reheat your carbonara using your microwave.

Here is how to reheat carbonara pasta and sauce in the microwave:

1. Place pasta into a microwave-safe bowl before pouring in some water. Make sure that there is enough water to submerge the pasta.
2. Heat for one minute, then stir. 
3. Replace the container in the microwave and reheat for another minute and stir.
4. Repeat the process until the pasta is warmed all the way through and drain the water or dump the pasta into a colander or spider strainer. Be careful not to overdo the cooking process to avoid turning the pasta into mush.
5. Place your carbonara sauce in a separate microwave-safe container and heat for 30 seconds. Stir, then microwave for another 30 seconds. Continue in 30-second intervals, if needed.

Once your noodles and your sauce have been reheated, proceed by mixing them thoroughly. Now, it is worth noting that you have to go through these motions, no matter how tedious they may seem.

For instance, simply throwing your pasta into the microwave might seem like the easier way to go about it, but it will likely lead to the microwave drying your noodles out. 

Reheating Carbonara Sauce and Pasta Together

Now, the next scenario entails reheating pasta that’s already been mixed with the carbonara sauce. Needless to say, this presents certain unique challenges. For instance, throwing the pasta into boiling water again is no longer a viable option. 

At the same time, you will also need to be extra careful about applying the right amount of heat.

For instance, if you overdo it, then you can easily burn your sauce while leaving your pasta cold. Instead, you will need to take your time to ensure that both the sauce and the pasta are evenly reheated.

1. Stovetop Method

When it comes to reheating carbonara, you will be dealing with the same set of problems that you once dealt with while cooking. Specifically, you will need to juggle two tasks at once.

First, you will need to ensure that the pasta is kept al dente during reheating. Secondly, you want to ensure that your sauce is heated properly and does not contain any lumps.

This may entail a lot of work on your part. However, the results are most definitely worth it, if done correctly. The stovetop method lets you do just that by giving you complete control over the heating process.

Follow these steps to reheat carbonara on the stovetop:

1. If you are taking your leftovers directly from the refrigerator, then we recommend that you leave it at room temperature for around 5 minutes to let its internal temperature come up and give you more flexibility during reheating.   
2. Place the pan on your stovetop and drizzle it with a bit of oil before turning on the heat. Keep the flame on medium. For the best results, use a non-stick pan to prevent your sauce from burning and sticking to the surface. 
3. Once the oil is hot enough, place the carbonara in the pan and start stirring. Keep stirring to ensure that the pasta doesn’t stick together or start burning. Take your time and keep the heat on medium. It should take no more than 5 minutes to heat the pasta thoroughly.
4. You’ll need to keep a close eye on your carbonara as it undergoes the process of reheating. If you feel that it is too dry, don’t hesitate to add a teaspoon of oil or cream to add more moisture. In addition to this, you can also refresh your pasta by adding some more herbs and spices into the mix. 
5. Once you have finished reheating the carbonara, add some fresh parmesan and parsley. This serves as an additional garnish to your dish and helps liven up your leftovers. If done correctly, you’d have a hard time convincing anyone that you are eating leftovers.

As you do this, we can’t overstate the importance of continuously stirring and turning the carbonara on the pan. This helps ensure that it is equally heated on all sides.

Another thing you have to take note of is the temperature of your pan. If you go overboard, the extreme heat will cause lumps to form on your sauce, effectively getting rid of the fine and creamy texture that is associated with this dish.

2. Microwave Method

Similar to the previous scenario, we only recommend using the microwave method if you find yourself pressed for time or without access to a stovetop.

This is because the microwave is not an ideal way to reheat carbonara. However, it can serve as a last resort. 

Here are the steps to reheat carbonara in the microwave:

1. Place leftover carbonara in a microwave-safe container. As you have probably figured out, you can no longer use the same method presented in the previous scenario because your pasta is already covered in sauce. So, submerging it in water is no longer an option.
2. Place your carbonara in the microwave. Make sure that your container doesn’t have a lid over it.
3. Use 1-minute bursts to reheat your carbonara. Make sure to stir and mix well after every cycle. Repeat this process until it is thoroughly reheated.
4. Keep an eye on the moisture level. The last thing you want is for your pasta to dry out during reheating. Remember that the sauce is what is preventing that from happening in the first place. However, if you find that the sauce isn’t enough to cover your pasta, then don’t hesitate to improvise. Adding a dash of water to your pasta will go a long way to prevent it from drying out.

Once the carbonara is properly reheated, give it a minute to rest before serving. Just remember that there will be some inevitable trade-offs if you decide to follow this method.

Specifically, you will be losing some of the fine texture that carbonara is known for. The worst-case scenario is that you will have a bowl of dried-out pasta covered in lumpy sauce.

We’ve laid out the different scenarios and methods available to you. So, if you ever find yourself needing to reheat carbonara on the fly, then you know what to do!

Up Next: Alfredo Vs Carbonara – What’s The Difference?