5 Best Toasters For Pop-Tarts [2023]

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

If you are a fan of Pop-Tarts, and they are your go-to meal in the morning on the way out the door, or as a treat in the afternoon, having the right appliance to perfectly toast the Pop-Tarts is a must.

Which are the best toasters for Pop-Tarts?

The best toasters for Pop-Tarts should have wide enough slots to fit in the Pop-Tarts, without having to squish them in, and the toaster should have a low heat setting to evenly heat the pastry without burning them.

Using the right toaster will ensure your Pop-Tarts are toasted to perfection each time, and you get to enjoy them at their best quality!

Read on to find out which toasters are the best for Pop-Tarts, and how to pick out the right one for you.

How To Choose The Best Toasters For Pop-Tarts

While most toasters can be used for Pop-Tarts, not all toasters are able to toast Pop-Tarts perfectly, and some might not have large enough slots, or have the right heat settings needed for Pop-Tarts.

Before purchasing a toaster, especially if you are planning on using it for Pop-Tarts, take a look at the below factors to look for:

Slot Size

There is no point in buying a toaster for Pop-Tarts if it isn’t going to fit the Pop-Tarts!

The slots should be long enough or wide enough to fit all of the pastry in.

If some of the Pop-Tart is left sticking out, it won’t toast evenly.

Slot Amount

Not only should you make sure that the toaster has wide-enough slots available for Pop-Tarts, but there should be enough slots available to suit your needs.

If you are just making Pop-Tarts for yourself, then a two-slot toaster would be ideal.

However, if you have a partner or family at home, a four-slice toaster is a much better option. You can find six-slot toasters if necessary too.

Heat Settings

Most toasters come with heat settings, so you can adjust the heat and time of the toaster to suit whatever it is that you are toasting.

For Pop-Tarts, it is best to choose a low-heat setting.

This helps to gently warm up the Pop-Tart from the inside out, without burning it on the outside.

The more adjustable the heat and time settings are on the toaster, the better, but as long as it has low, medium, and high, it should give you everything you need.


While you might be looking for a toaster specifically for Pop-Tarts, it does help to find one that is versatile in your kitchen too!

Other than being able to toast bread and Pop-Tarts, look to see if the toaster has other functions too, such as defrosting, bagel settings, and waffle toasting. These can all come in handy in the kitchen.

Easy Cleaning

You want a toaster that is low maintenance and easy to clean so that it lasts for a long time in your kitchen without declining in quality too much.

The toaster should have a removable crumb tray that makes throwing out the old crumbs and bits easy, and the surface should be easy enough to wipe down and clean when necessary.

The 5 Best Toasters For Pop-Tarts

You want to enjoy your Pop-Tarts the way they were meant to be enjoyed, and the best way to do this is to have the perfect toaster at home to make Pop-Tarts!

Here are the best toasters to buy to make Pop-Tarts at home, as well as to make some toast, warm-up bagels, and more!

RankProductKey Features
1.Bella 2 Slice Toaster Wide slots, drop-down crumb tray, 6 shade settings.
2.Gevi Toaster 4 Slice Touchscreen controls, 4 slots, removable crumb trays,
3.Cusimax Stainless Steel Toaster 1.5-inch extra-wide toaster, LED display setting.
4.Elite Gourmet Long Slot Toaster Extra-wide slots, drop-down crumb tray, reheat function.
5.Redmond Retro Stainless Steel Toaster 4 extra-wide slots, independent controls, retro design.

1. Bella 2 Slice Toaster

Check Current Price On Amazon

The Bella 2 Slice Toaster has extra-wide slots, which easily fit in Pop-Tarts, bagels, waffles, and even more.

The slots even have a self-centering guide, to ensure even heating.

There is a drop-down crumb tray which is removable, making cleaning the toaster much easier.

A built-in cord storage area helps to keep your counter space clutter-free.

The smaller size makes it ideal for many kitchens, but it is still ideal for Pop-Tarts.

The toaster has 6 shade settings, where you can choose the heat setting and how browned your Pop-Tarts and toast becomes.

There is also a reheat function which is ideal for Pop-Tarts too.

The high lift lever allows for easy access to your Pop-Tarts, so you can get eating as soon as they are done!

2. Gevi Toaster 4 Slice

Check Current Price On Amazon

If you are looking for a toaster for your family, the Gevi Toaster 4 Slice is a great option, not to mention it is wonderfully stylish too!

The touchscreen design of the toaster gives you complete control of the heat and time your Pop-Tarts are toasted to.

The four extra-wide slots have double independent controls, so you can toast different items at the same time.

With basic selections of bagel, defrost, heat, and heat settings, you will be able to perfectly toast up to 4 Pop-Tarts at the same time.

There are 2 removable crumb trays for easy cleaning, helping you keep the toaster in the best condition possible.

3. Cusimax Stainless Steel Toaster

Check Current Price On Amazon

The Cusimax Stainless Steel Toaster has 1.5-inch extra-wide slots, perfect to fit in Pop-Tarts without having to squash them in.

The stainless steel housing of the toaster makes it durable and stylish, and easy to clean as well.

It offers even and fast toasting, and you can adjust the heat setting to suit what your Pop-Tarts need!

A super-clear LED display on the front helps you count down the time left until your Pop-Tarts are done, as well as shows the heat setting the toaster is on.

You can choose between 6 different heat settings.

There are three additional buttons on the toaster – including cancel, bagel and defrost, so this toaster is sure to suit all your needs in the kitchen!

4. Elite Gourmet Long Slot Toaster

Check Current Price On Amazon

Pop-Tarts will easily fit into the Elite Gourmet Long Slot Toaster, as the slots measure 1.5 inches wide.

This can fit Pop-Tarts, extra-thick slices of toast, bagels, and waffles.

There are 6 adjustable toasting levels, so you can choose the one best suited to your Pop-Tarts, and whatever else it is that you might need to toast.

You are also able to use the reheat and warming function, to reheat your Pop-Tarts to perfection before eating them.

A retractable warming rack helps to warm pastries, buns, croissants, and more. There is also a drop-down crumb tray for easy cleaning too.

5. Redmond Retro Stainless Steel Toaster

Check Current Price On Amazon

Perfect for a family, the Redmond Retro Stainless Steel Toaster has 4 slots, measuring 5.5 by 1.5 inches.

The toaster slots are ideal for Pop-Tarts, bagels, English muffins, and more.

Choose between 6 browning levels, with the lowest settings being suitable to toast the perfect Pop-Tarts.

With a stainless steel design, the toaster is durable and long-lasting, and it will look really great in your kitchen too.

Each side of the toaster, each with 2 slots, can be independently controlled with the various buttons and dials, giving you complete control over how you toast your Pop-Tarts and bread.

With a retro design, and all the functions needed to be a great toaster for Pop-Tarts, this toaster is also ideal for everything else that needs toasting in your kitchen too!

If you’re looking for more like this, check out my guide to the best retro toasters.

Summing it all up

Above, we have gone through everything you need to consider when picking out the best toaster to have at home for your Pop-Tarts, as well as some of the best options on the market at the moment!

With the right toaster, you can toast your Pop-Tarts to perfection, whether making one or two in the morning for yourself or multiple Pop-Tarts as a treat for the family.

Make sure to choose a toaster that will not only be great for Pop-Tarts, but that will suit your kitchen and your needs too!

Related Questions

Can you eat Pop-Tarts out of the box?

Pop-Tarts can be eaten straight out of the box, but they won’t be as appetizing. They will be hard and probably taste stale too.

They need to be warmed up to become soft, toasted, and slightly melted, which is how they are supposed to be enjoyed.

Does the icing on Pop-Tarts melt?

The icing on Pop-Tarts becomes soft when heated in the toaster, but it will not melt, as it was designed to retain its texture and consistency when heated up.

This prevents it from dripping down into the toaster and making a mess.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *