3 Best Retro Toasters Of 2023

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

A retro-looking toaster adds so much to the kitchen. With an old-fashioned design yet innovative features, this kitchen appliance is both beautiful and functional. 

But what is the best retro toaster? The best retro toaster has appropriate dimensions for your counter, is made of a durable material, has slots wide enough for a variety of bread types, and any desired settings. It should also have a range of browning levels.

When choosing a good retro toaster, there are a few things to consider aside from its design and color. You’ll want to pay attention to all the little details as well. And remember: the more levels the toaster has the better.

If you have been on the hunt for a retro toaster but haven’t been able to make a decision yet, this article is for you. Read on to learn more about the best retro toasters.

Retro Toasters: What To Consider 

If you are wondering what’s different about retro toasters, the answer is the design. Generally speaking, these toasters are the same as regular toasters. It is their retro and nostalgic design that sets them apart from others. 

Retro toasters mostly come in pastel colors. Red and white retro toasters are widely popular too. 

Adding a retro vibe to your kitchen may be your main concern with these toasters. However, there are other things to consider too. 

Toaster Dimensions

No one buys a stylish retro toaster to keep it in a kitchen cabinet. And if you are going to display it, make sure to buy a toaster that will fit nicely on your kitchen counter. 


The body material of the toaster is important. If you have a big family and need lots of toasted bread in the mornings, consider buying a toaster with a stainless steel body as it doesn’t get hot after many rounds of toasting bread. 

Slots Dimensions

The length and width of the slots is also an important aspect of any toaster. If you like toasting bagels and all sorts of artisan bread, choosing a retro toaster with wide slots would be wise. 

The length of the slots also differs depending on the size of the toaster itself, so it’s worth checking out all the dimensions. 

Toast Levels 

Choose a retro toaster with multiple toasting or browning levels to achieve perfect results no matter how toasted you want your bread to be. 

Other Features

Other features you should consider are the specific settings of the toaster, whether it has a removable crumb tray or not, whether the lever is automatic or manual, etc. 

3 Best Retro Toasters 

These are three of the best retro toasters you can find on the market. You cannot go wrong with any of them:

RankProductKey Features
1.KEEMO Retro Small Toaster2 slots, 6 browning levels, 10.2x7x6.3”
2.Nostalgia 2-Slice Toaster2 slots, 5 browning levels, 18.5x15.3x11.3”
3.Smeg Retro Toaster2 slots, 6 browning levels, 12.7x7.6x7.7”

Keep reading for more information about these fabulously old-school toasters!

1. KEEMO Retro Small Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon 

Key Features:

  • Bagel, defrost, and ‘cancel’ functions
  • One-touch buttons that light up when pressed
  • Cord space for easy storage
  • Automatic pop-up
  • Toast shade and time control 
  • Easy-reach lever

If you are after a retro toaster with a simple design and a compact size, then the KEEMO small retro toaster will certainly fit your taste. 

This toaster is very compact. However, it can fit two wide slices of bread or bagel. 

The steel body makes this toaster a long-term investment to your kitchen appliances collection. It is rust-free and easy to maintain due to the removable crumb tray and smooth surface. 

2. Nostalgia Wide 2-Slice Toaster 

Check Current Price on Amazon 

Key Features:

  • Two extra-wide slots
  • Bagel, defrost, and ‘cancel’ buttons 
  • Cord storage for a neat-looking kitchen counter
  • Preferred browning level (1 to 5)
  • Auto-adjusting timer
  • Easy to clean due to the sliding tray

Are you looking for the most retro-looking toaster on the market? Here it is. This bright red Nostalgia toaster will steal your heart. The white sides and steel details complete the look, making this toaster unmistakably a retro one. 

While the top material of this toaster is plastic, the good thing about it is that it makes the toaster quite lightweight. 

If you like toasting not only bread but also muffins and bagels, the extra-wide 1.5-inch thick slots will work perfectly for you.  

3. Smeg 50’s Retro Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon 

Key Features: 

  • Automatic pop-up
  • Control knob with six browning settings
  • Stainless steel bread lift 
  • Reheat, defrost, and bagel settings
  • Non-slipping feet
  • Touch release crumb tray 

If you are willing to pay a higher price for an old-fashioned but high-quality toaster, then the Smeg toasters are something to consider.

But the design is not the only selling point of these toasters. They are also well-built and durable with a predominantly steel construction. 

Additionally, these toasters come in a range of colors. You will certainly find one that fits your kitchen aesthetic. 

The Smeg 50s-style toasters have all the functions you need. But what makes people go crazy over them is the timeless design. These toasters are elegant, retro, and sleek all at the same time.  

Up Next: 5 Best Small And Compact Toasters

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *