The 5 Best Non-Stick Baking Sheets Of 2023
Baking can be an easy and effortless cooking task only if you have a truly non-stick baking sheet. Otherwise, the scrubbing that you have to do after the dinner takes away from the food you have just enjoyed.
What are the best non-stick baking sheets? A good non-stick baking sheet should have a long-lasting protective nonstick coating. They should be durable and warp-resistant. Aluminum distributes heat well and cools down quickly, but steel is still appropriate for home cooks. Size, design, and color depend on taste and intended uses.
If the above criteria are met, the rest is up to you to decide. To find the best non-stick baking sheet that will work for you, you have to factor in what you need.
In this article, we have picked five of the best non-stick baking sheets. Continue reading for a closer look at these kitchen staples that will make your life so much easier.
Choosing a Non-Stick Baking Sheet
If you are looking for a non-stick baking sheet, then you have already made your mind on the finish.
Non-stick baking sheets are a good choice as compared to the ones without the non-stick coating they clean well. Most importantly, they clean effortlessly.
Aside from the finish, there are several things you need to consider before buying a baking sheet.
Material
Baking sheets are generally made from aluminum and steel. If you are picky with heat distribution, then go with aluminum baking sheets. Aluminum also cools down quicker. So, if this is what you need, then buy aluminum baking sheets.
Steel baking sheets can also be very durable and long-lasting if you pick the right one. Unlike aluminum baking sheets that are sensitive to acidic food, steel ones aren’t. All in all, steel sheets are a versatile choice for amateur home cooks.
No matter which material you choose, good care and maintenance coupled with the quality of the product can make your baking sheet last for years.
Size
If there is a specific size of a baking sheet you need, for example, larger than usual or very small, buy those. But if you don’t have a baking sheet and need one, go for the standard-sized baking sheets.
Half-sheet pans are most popular as their size works perfectly for most ovens. These pans usually measure around 13 x 18 inches.
With this being said, measure your oven before buying a baking sheet to avoid unpleasant surprises. You go to test your bakeware with a batch of cookies only to find out that it doesn’t even fit in your oven.
Another great option is buying a set of baking sheets. Having the same baking sheet in different sizes will not only let you bake in different portions but also look nice stacked together.
Design
If you are looking for baking sheets to bake cookies, you may be tempted to buy a cookie sheet without edges. This is technically a baking sheet too.
However, it is not as versatile as cookie sheets in many cases don’t have edges to make sliding cookies easy.
Even if you are planning to buy a baking sheet to use only for cookies, don’t buy an edgeless one. Buy a baking sheet with raised edges that you can use not only to bake cookies but a range of other things too, including veggies and meat.
Also, pay attention to the handles. Classic baking sheets usually don’t have any. If you need a baking sheet with handles to ensure a nice grip, there are many options on the market.
Color
You may think that the color of the baking sheet should be the least of your worries. However, if you didn’t know, the color of the sheet has a lot to do with the cooking time.
The darker the baking sheet the more quickly it cooks. The reason for this is that darker colors absorb more heat.
Thus, if you are confused about why your cookies turn brown whenever you bake with your dark cookie sheets and follow the instructions, this is why.
If you are someone that wants to have cookware and bakeware of the same color, you might consider this question from another perspective.
However, knowing that the color of bakeware has its impact on the cooking time will be helpful in your future baking adventures.
You may need to adjust the timing and the baking temperature with darker sheets.
The general rule is using lower heat, 25 °F lower than indicated in cooking instructions. Alternatively, you may need to leave the food in the oven for a few minutes longer.
Or, you simply need to check on whatever you are baking often. After a few times of baking with darker sheets, you will surely get the hang of it.
5 Best Non-Stick Baking Sheets
If you are trying to up your baking game, then non-stick baking sheets should be on your bakeware wishlist.
Here are our top 5 non-stick baking sheet options:
| Rank | Product | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Nordic Ware Commercial Baker’s Half-Sheet | Superior heat conductivity |
| 2. | Rachel Ray Nonstick Bakeware Set | Silicone handles |
| 3. | Good Cook Non-Stick Cookie Sheet Set | Comes in a pack of 3 |
| 4. | USA Pan Bakeware Half-Sheet Pan | Corrugated surface |
| 5. | Farberware Nonstick Bakeware Set | Warp-resistant |
No matter which one you choose, it will be easy to clean and durable! Read on for more information about each of these great pans.
1. Nordic Ware Natural Aluminum Commercial Baker’s Half Sheet
Key Features:
- Pure natural aluminum
- Scratch-resistant
- Comes in a pack of two
Have you ever wondered why professional cooks choose aluminum baking sheets? Because they are long-lasting and stand out with their superb heat conductivity.
What makes this baking sheet one of the best on the market is that while it is made from natural uncoated aluminum, it has an extremely smooth surface that remains clean after every use.
If you are someone that wants to avoid the non-stick coatings but still enjoy the perks of non-stick bakeware, then these baking sheets will work perfectly for you.
Aluminum baking sheets react with acidic foods, such as tomatoes or vinegar. If this is not something that worries you, then this Nordic Ware baking sheet is a real find for you.
2. Rachel Ray Nonstick Bakeware Set with Grips
Key Features:
- Wide comfortable handles
- Oven-safe to 500 °F
- Comes in a set of three
If baking sheets with a classic design and shape are what you are looking for, then this Rachel Ray non-stick bakeware set might be your new favorite.
What sets these baking sheets apart are their handles with silicone pads. Not only they will bring diversity to your bakeware collection but what is more important, they will provide a secure grip on hot baking sheets.
Coming in three different sizes, having a set of these baking sheets will cover all your baking, roasting, and toasting needs.
Being made of heavy gauge steel, you will not experience any warping with these trays. This may be a problem with low-quality steel baking sheets but surely not with these.
3. Good Cook Non-Stick Cookie Sheet, Set of 3
Key Features:
- Top-quality non-stick coating
- A set of three non-stick pans
- Dishwasher-safe
Looking for a reasonably-priced set of baking sheets that will get the job done? Here you have it.
These cookie sheets by Good Cook will not only bake your cookies evenly but also satisfy your other baking needs. The design of these baking sheets is simple yet thoughtful and increases the durability of the bakeware.
Additionally, these baking sheets are dishwasher safe. We recommend cleaning your baking sheets by hand, especially as they are that easy to clean. However, knowing that you can wash your bakeware in the dishwasher is always a relief.
4. USA Pan Bakeware Half Sheet Pan
Key Features:
- Heavy-gauge aluminized steel
- A BPA-free coating
- Corrugated surface
If you want to invest in a standard-sized non-stick baking sheet, then this USA Pan half-sheet pan might be your best bet.
What makes this baking sheet unique is its corrugated surface. It promotes air circulation resulting in evenly baked cookies, cakes, and vegetables.
The coating on this baking sheet is silicone. However, nothing will leach into your food as it is free of any nasty chemicals.
Being made of aluminized steel, you don’t have to worry about the durability of this product. No wonder baking sheets manufactured from this material are often preferred by professional cooks.
5. Farberware Nonstick Bakeware Set
Key Features:
- Oven-safe to 450 °F
- Even heating with no hot spots
- Comes in a set of two
If you want to buy a non-stick baking sheet that will be good for not only baking but roasting, then this Faberware set is worth paying attention to.
These steel baking sheets are very durable and won’t warp even on high heat. They are also easy to clean and the handles make it so much easier to pull these baking sheets out of the oven.
The Farberware baking sheets heat evenly. Thus, you won’t have to deal with cookies with burnt edges.
While many people experience hot spots and uneven heating with low-quality steel baking sheets, this is certainly not the case with the Farberware ones.
