9 Best K-Cup Teas To Buy In 2023

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

Drinking a cozy mug of tea is one of life’s greatest small pleasures. A great way to enjoy your perfect cup of tea quickly and easily is by using K-Cup teas in your Keurig compatible tea or coffee maker. 

There are hundreds of tea flavors and blends, so when it comes to the best option, you will have to decide what you’re looking for in your tea.

Do you need something stimulating that contains caffeine? Are you looking for a soothing herbal tea blend? Maybe you want specific health benefits.

Whatever the purpose is, there is going to be a tea out there for you that you can use in your K-Cup coffee and tea maker. 

So, how do you choose the best K-Cup teas? You want to look for teas without added preservatives, colors, or sugars. You will also want to choose organic if possible and look for K-Cup pods that are recyclable. 

Read on to discover how to choose the best K-Cup tea and 9 of the best brands I’ve found!

How To Choose The Best K-Cup Teas 

Finding the best K-Cup tea can be a daunting task with so many different companies and products to choose from. It’s important to consider a few key factors when selecting your favorite tea.

What Do You Want Your Tea To Do?

Sometimes you might need your cup of tea to help you wake up in the morning, in which case you’ll want to look for a caffeinated tea such as black, oolong, green, or white tea.

If you want your tea to be a little more relaxing there are many herbal blends such as chamomile or rooibos for you to try. 

Drinking tea is also a simple and delicious way to sip on some nutrients, so you might choose a tea based on the specific health benefits of its ingredients.

Whatever your purpose, I have provided a variety of teas to suit all of these different needs and preferences below. 

No Added Preservatives or Colors

Generally speaking, it doesn’t really matter what color your tea is when it comes to how it tastes.

Different teas will have slightly different colors ranging from a deep brown to a bright red to a pale green and everything in between. 

Adding colors to your tea is an aesthetic choice that has no impact on taste or nutrition. However, in some cases, it can cause allergic reactions in susceptible people.

When it comes to preservatives, the K-Cup packaging is designed to keep your tea fresh, so you don’t need to add anything extra. 

No Added Sugars

Drinking a cup of tea is a highly individual experience that is based on personal preference. When buying K-Cup or prepackaged teas, there may also be some hidden sources of sugars or artificial sweeteners in the final product. 

These sweeteners can change the flavor of your tea and contribute to liquid calories.

Look for no sugar added K-Cup tea pods and then use your own favorite sweetener, such as honey, if you want to add some extra sweetness to your tea. 


Tea leaves and herbs are quite delicate and can be prone to attack from pests and garden bugs. That often means that they can be heavily sprayed or processed in ways that may not produce the healthiest tea product.

Since many commonly consumed teas were found to be contaminated with heavy metals, choosing organic brands is a great option to help limit your exposure to potentially harmful chemicals. 

I have included a few organic and traditional brands below so that you can choose the option that is best for your goals and your budget.

Recyclable or Compostable Packaging

While the convenience of using K-Cup is certainly appealing, they can create a lot of plastic waste since most of the original cups were made of several layers of plastic that need to be separated before recycling. 

Municipal recycling facilities generally didn’t take that step, so most K-Cup pods ended up in the landfill.

You can help to balance convenience and plastic waste by choosing K-Cup tea pods that come in recyclable or compostable packaging

Best Caffeinated K-Cup Teas

Below are my top picks for best caffeinated K-Cup teas. All of these options are great for when you need that extra bit of energy in the morning or even if you’re just looking for a tea that tastes great.

RankProductBest Feature
1.Maud'sBest overall K-Cup tea
2.TejavaBest flavored black K-Cup tea
3.WellOff Beautify MeBest fruit-blend K-Cup tea
4.Super Organics Metabolism TeaBest metabolism-boosting K-Cup tea
5.VitaCup Green TeaBest overall green K-Cup tea
6.Organa Green TeaPan-fired green tea leaves
7.WellOff Slumber MeBest overall decaffeinated K-Cup tea
8.Organa Lemon ChamomileBest lemon chamomile K-Cup tea
9.VitaCup De-StressBest stress-relieving K-Cup tea
Runner-UpFGO OrganicGreat organic green K-Cup tea

1. Maud’s

Check Current Price on Amazon

This tea takes the number one spot for a few reasons.

Firstly, it’s made from pure organic tea leaves from premier growing regions around the world.

This California-based company cares about the environment and uses solar energy to produce each batch of tea. They aim to be carbon neutral by 2024.

Maud’s English Breakfast Tea mixes Assam, Ceylon, and Kenyan teas to produce a robust blend that is made with 100% USDA Organic Kosher certified ingredients.

The K-Cups are recyclable and the tea doesn’t contain any added preservatives, colors, or sweeteners. 

If you want to try more of their flavors, they offer a sampler pack that includes Green Tea, Black Tea, Peppermint Tea, Chai Tea, Matcha Tea, Jasmine Tea, Chamomile Lavender, English Breakfast & Earl Grey.

2. Tejava

Check Current Price on Amazon

If you’re looking for a black tea with a little bit of a twist, this choice contains natural peach flavors.

This subtle fruitiness makes it the perfect black tea to use for summer.

It tastes delicious when chilled and iced with a touch of honey or sweetener.

Brew up a batch and bring it on your next picnic.

These K-Cups are BPA-free and recyclable. This tea contains no added sugars, colors, or preservatives and is made from Non-GMO-verified, Rainforest Alliance-certified tea leaves.

Even though it’s not organic, the tea still comes from a source the supports the environment and creates a healthy tea. 

They also offer other flavors such as a Vanilla Chai Black Tea, an Apple Cinnamon Black Tea, and a Pineapple Mango Black Tea

If you’re not sure what you prefer, you can purchase a sampler pack that includes 6 different types of tea, one being a plain black tea option.

3. WellOff Beautify Me

Check Current Price on Amazon

This tea brand makes the list because it offers a nice choice for those looking for a lighter tea.

White tea is still caffeinated, but isn’t as strong as black or green tea and can have a higher level of antioxidants.

WellOff Elixirs are organic and come in recyclable packaging

All added ingredients are USDA-certified organic and provide natural flavor and extra health benefits. This brand doesn’t contain any added sugars, artificial sweeteners, preservatives, or artificial ingredients. 

This blend contains apple, blueberry, strawberry, and raspberry for a delicious fruity taste that’s delicious, warm or chilled.

They also offer a variety pack that contains 8 different teas that range from an anti-inflammatory Turmeric Blend to a fresh Lemon Ginger.

4. Super Organics Metabolism Tea

Check Current Price on Amazon

Another great organic, caffeinated tea choice is the Super Organics Oolong blend.

This blend contains Yerba Mate, orange, garcinia cambogia, and rosehip to help boost metabolism.

These additions also add a great flavor to the tea. 

There are no added sugars, preservatives, or colors, and they even add some probiotics to support gut health.

This company uses recyclable and eco-friendly materials that can be composted so that you aren’t adding to the landfill every time you have a cup of tea. 

They also offer a beauty-boosting green tea made with skin-loving ingredients like chrysanthemum, grape seed, and rosehip. 

Or if you’re looking for a black tea, they have a choice that is blended with maca, ginger, vanilla bean, and cinnamon. 

5. VitaCup Green Tea

Check The Current Price on Amazon

The VitaCup Green Tea Pods aren’t certified organic, but they don’t contain any added sugars, colors, or preservatives.

This brand also has packaging that is recyclable and compatible with all K-Cup brewing machines.

This brand contains added nutrients such as moringa, concentrated matcha green tea, and added B vitamins.

I wanted to include this brand because they don’t just offer green tea, but provide a few other delicious caffeinated options for every taste.

If you’re looking for a chai spice black tea, then their Genius Blend is the perfect choice.

Looking for some digestive support? Their Immunity Probiotic Blend contains green tea, aloe, peppermint, and probiotics.

Finally they offer a Slim Tea Blend made from oolong and acai berry.

6. Organa Green Tea

Check Current Price on Amazon

This tea is made from 100% USDA-certified organic green tea leaves that are pan-fired for a gourmet flavor.

Organa tea doesn’t contain any added sugars, colors, or preservatives.

This makes it a great option for those looking for a pure green tea with no added flavors. 

Unfortunately, the K-Cup pods don’t appear to be recyclable, so that is something to keep in mind when purchasing. Otherwise, this brand is a great choice for the green tea lovers out there. 

The also offer Vanilla Earl Grey, English Breakfast, and Chai Black Tea flavors.

Best Decaffeinated K-Cup Teas

Now that I’ve gone over my favorite caffeinated K-Cup teas, let’s continue the list by taking a look at some decaffeinated options. These cups are perfect for later in the evening or if you’re just not a fan of caffeine.

7. WellOff Slumber Me

Check Current Price on Amazon

The WellOff Elixirs Organic Chamomile and Lavender tea pod takes top spot in the decaffeinated category.

It doesn’t contain any added colors, preservatives, or sweeteners.

The packaging is recyclable and the ingredients are certified organic. 

It also contains an easily absorbable bisglycinate form of magnesium that is gentle on the belly for increased relaxation. The combination of lavender, chamomile, and magnesium will have you drifting off to dreamland in no time. 

8. Organa Lemon Chamomile

Check Current Price on Amazon

Chamomile tea is one of the best teas you can drink to help unwind at the end of your day as you get ready for bed.

It’s incredibly soothing and has a lovely flavor.

Combined with the lemon in this tea blend and maybe a touch of honey, the taste is bright, fresh, and comforting.

This brand uses organic chamomile blossoms and has no added sugars, preservatives, or colors. The K-Cups aren’t recyclable, so if that is important to you this might not be the best brand to choose. 

9. VitaCup De-Stress

Check Current Price on Amazon

If you are looking for a tea to help calm your racing mind and relax after a stressful day, then this K- Cup tea is the perfect choice for you.

They are made with recyclable plastic that keeps your tea fresh and can stay out of the landfill. 

Their blend is a delicious combination of chamomile, valerian root, and rooibos tea, which is a great caffeine-free blend.

It also contains a combination of lavender, lemon balm, and a hint of peppermint and vanilla for a delicious flavor and even more soothing benefits. 

This company likes to up their nutrition game by adding extra nutrients such as a blend of B vitamins and L-theanine, an amino acid that promotes relaxation. 

While the ingredients aren’t organic, they still provide a lot of health benefits with no added colors, preservatives, or sweeteners. 

If you’re looking for more decaffeinated tea blends from this company you can try their Beauty Blend Rooibos tea that is packed with collagen, biotin, and folate to help promote hair, skin, and nail growth.

Runner-Up Green Tea: FGO Organic

Check Current Price on Amazon

This last tea is a runner-up on my list because of green tea’s popularity right now.

This option is caffeinated so make sure to keep that in mind if you’re looking for a caffeine-free option.

The FGO brand offers a great value for USDA-certified organic green tea, so it might be a great choice for you. 

The packaging isn’t recyclable, but it doesn’t contain any added colors, preservatives, flavors, or sweeteners, so it’s perfect for the people looking for a pure green tea taste.

They also offer a money-back guarantee if you don’t enjoy their product, which is helpful if you’re trying out different brands. 

Final Thoughts

Purchasing a tea is an individual process that relies heavily on your taste preference and whether you’re looking for a stimulating or a relaxing tea blend.

When shopping, keep in mind the important factors that include recyclable packaging and no added colors, flavors, preservatives, or sweeteners.

I hope I was able to provide you with a broad range of flavors, blends, brands, and caffeinated or caffeine-free options so that you can find a tea for every occasion.

There are new brands and blends popping up every day, so don’t be afraid to try something new.

With summer fast approaching, many of these blends will taste great chilled with a splash of lemon and honey for a cooling drink on a hot day.

With the knowledge gained from this article, you should be able to quickly and easily deduce whether a K-Cup tea pod is the right choice for you, regardless of whether they made it onto this list.

Have fun looking for new choices and happy tea drinking! 

Up Next: 9 Best Self-Stirrer Mugs Of 2021

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *