7 Best Honey Mustard Brands Of 2023

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

Honey mustard is undoubtedly one of the most popular condiments around – adding flavor to a wide array of dishes.

A widely popular variant of the already popular condiment, honey mustard highlights the best qualities of any savory dish, while adding a bit of sweetness.

There is no denying the crucial role it plays in the kitchen. It is one of the most versatile condiments that you can get your hand on. So, it is hardly surprising to find that it is a staple in many homes.

From salad dressing and sandwich spreads to more complex dishes, the sweet and tangy flavor of honey mustard offers a myriad of possibilities. 

But what are the best honey mustard brands? The best brands of honey mustard will vary by personal preference, but they should all have a good balance of the sweet honey flavor and tangy, tart mustard flavor. Type of mustard seed or honey as well as any additional seasoning are worth noting by preference.

Be sure to keep reading and make sure to give our picks a try. You might just find the brand that works perfectly with your favorite dishes.     

Understanding Mustard Varieties and Honey Mustard 

Most people don’t seem to realize that mustard sauce is among the world’s oldest condiments. It has a rich history that can be traced back to ancient times.

Early Roman cooks are credited with making the earliest predecessor of mustard  as we’re familiar with it, grinding the seeds into a paste and mixing it with wine or vinegar – an ancient spread!

French monks in started mixing ground mustard seeds with an unfermented grape juice to make a hot paste, mustum ardens – and appear to be the source of the word ‘mustard’ (taking part of must-um and ard-ens).

As it happens, honey has not only been a historic additive, honey mustard is also an incredible popular modern variety.

The difference in many mustards lies mainly in which type of liquid you mix in with the ground mustard seeds. 

For instance, many recipes require vinegar or wine to provide the necessary flavors. Other recipes require the use of beer or even lemon juice.

The acidity of the liquid, mixed with the seed’s oils, helps create the desired flavors. Listed below are just some of the most popular kinds of mustard sauce that you can try:

  • Dijon – One of the spicier varieties of the sauce, it takes its name from its place of origin. It is made from brown mustard seeds and white wine.
  • Yellow – This is probably the most accessible and popular form of mustard sauce. It is undoubtedly the thing that comes to mind when you think of mustard. Yellow mustard is also known as American mustard. It is most commonly used on hot dogs and burgers.
  • German – A broad category in its own right, German mustard also comes in regional varieties. For instance, Bavarian mustards are known to have a sweeter palate while Düsseldorf mustard packs more of a punch in terms of heat. However, the first thing that comes to mind when we say German mustard is Mittelscharf, the most well-known.
  • Beer – Another American invention, beer mustard uses the popular everyman drink as the sauce’s base liquid. Needless to say, this creates an interesting flavor profile that should not be missed.
  • Creole – If you have ever had a po’boy or a remoulade in Louisiana, then you will have undoubtedly tried this regional mustard variant.  It has a distinctively grainy texture as well as a surprisingly spicy flavor. It is worth noting that creole mustard uses vinegar as its base liquid which gives it the desired acidity. 

Now, as you have probably figured out. Honey mustard is made using the same concepts provided above.

More often than not, it is a 1:1 blend of honey and mustard. In most cases, companies make use of yellow mustard when creating their honey mustard recipe.

Honey plays a major role in the flavor notes of these mustard varieties. It tempers some of the heat and bitterness that characterizes and defines many mustards. Instead, with honey added, you get a sauce with the right level of sweetness and an infinitely more complex flavor profile. 

Uses For Honey Mustard

This is made especially apparent by the sauce’s myriad of possible applications. Listed here are some of the most popular uses for Honey Mustard.

  • Brushing Sauce – Honey mustard is perfect for brushing on chicken or pork as it cooks. Incredibly simple and straightforward, it is impossible to mess up. Moreover, it never fails to create show-stopping results.
  • Spread – If you are working on fish fillets, then you can never go wrong with some honey mustard. Salmon, in particular, works perfectly with this kind of sauce. 
  • Dipping Sauce – Honey mustard brings that perfect combination of sweet and savory. This unique combination makes it perfect for pairing with a wide array of food. 
  • Vinaigrette – A teaspoon of honey mustard will give your vinaigrette some much-needed balance. At the same time, the honey mustard also works as an emulsifier, something every salad dressing needs.

Buyer’s Guide To Honey Mustard

The mixture of honey and mustard is a match made in heaven. After all, both of these ingredients can be listed among the versatile in the kitchen. So, the prospect of putting them together into a sauce isn’t all that surprising.  

Of course, this is not to say that all honey mustard brands are made the same. Far from it. Remember that honey mustard is a blend of two essential ingredients.

While most brands follow the same principles in making their respective sauces, the subtle differences in ingredients and processes ultimately make some sauces better than others.

This is precisely what you need to look into: the type of honey and the mustard used to make the sauce itself. Take note that, in some cases, the differences between sauces can be subtle. In others, it can be quite overwhelming and unique. 

Type and Origin of Honey

There is a common misconception that all honey is supposed to taste the same. However, as any professional chef would tell you, the origin of a particular ingredient has a profound effect on its taste and flavor. 

Needless to say, it’s no different for honey. This is because the process of making honey is naturally dependent on its immediate surroundings.

Remember that bees make it by taking pollen from local and seasonal flowers. So, honey made in the Midwest will surely have subtle differences compared to honey made in England or Taiwan. 

Naturally, it is important to read the fine print when looking at different honey mustard brands. This is because some brands will go so far as to identify the specific type of honey and even the flower source they used during the production process.

In addition to this, you will also want to look at whether they used raw honey or processed honey. The latter usually entails whipping or creaming. However, most major brands likely contain a honey blend that has been heat-pasteurized. 

Type of Mustard Seed

Aside from honey, another important factor that you need to consider is the type of mustard you’re your sauce is made from. There are three types of mustard seed from which a myriad of varieties stem from. 

Namely, you have the white, brown, and black mustard seeds. The main difference between these three seed types is the level of heat they provide to the sauce itself.

White mustard seeds are known to be the mildest of the bunch. Conversely, black mustard seeds are known to have the most intense flavors. Brown mustard seeds, also commonly known as Indian Mustard, fall somewhere in the middle.

Knowing the difference between these three is of utmost importance. After all, they will play a major role in terms of how the sauce itself will ultimately turn out.   

Top Picks for the Best Honey Mustard Brands

Now that you have a better idea of the things you need to consider when shopping for honey mustard, it is time for us to delve into the matter at hand.

These honey mustard brands have earned a spot among the very best in their category, in our humble opinion:

1.Beaver Sweet Honey MustardSweet with classic mustard kick
2.Inglehoffer Honey MustardMild, sweet, and tangy
3.Boar's Head Honey MustardSweet and tangy
4.Stonewall Kitchen Sweet Honey MustardBalance of sweet and savory
5.Woeber's Reserve Honey MustardSweet and tangy
6.Kraft Honey Mustard DressingSweet, flavorful, tangy
7.Robert Rothschild Farm Raspberry Honey MustardSweet, notes of tart raspberry

So fire up the grill, turn the oven on, or get your sandwiches ready, ’cause one of these bad boys is sure to work for you!

1. Beaver Sweet Honey Mustard

Check Current Price on Amazon

At the top of our list, we have the Beaver sweet honey mustard!

If the name sounds familiar, it is probably because Beaver is one of the top condiment manufacturers around.

It is a specialty brand that has tried its hand in making everything from horseradish, ketchup, salsa, and even wasabi.

Now, they have come up with their honey mustard sauce, and it is truly our favorite honey mustard out there!

It features bold, spicy flavors that are perfectly offset with the sweetness of the honey. It is a truly classic flavor that anyone will appreciate.

You’ll also be glad to know that the Beaver honey mustard is one of the healthiest options out there. It caters specifically to people with special dietary needs.

Not only is it low-calorie and vegetarian, but it is also completely gluten-free and contains no trans fats. It also has zero cholesterol and preservatives.

So, if you are looking to switch to a healthier diet, then this honey mustard is a step in the right direction!

2. Inglehoffer Honey Mustard

Check Current Price on Amazon

If you are a fan of deviled eggs and egg salads, then the Inglehoffer Honey Mustard sauce would be the perfect choice for you.

Of course, you can also choose to use it on your hotdogs, burgers, and sandwiches.

The distinctive zing coupled with the right level of sweetness makes it perfect for any time of day.

In addition to this, you will also love the level of convenience it provides. Specifically, we simply loved the squeezable bottles – nothing should get in the way of enjoying a fresh, hot meal.

These sauces come in ergonomically designed squeeze bottles with travel-friendly flip caps. Just squeeze for more! They’re convenient to use for adults and kids alike.

3. Boar’s Head Honey Mustard

Check Current Price on Amazon

Next up, we have Boar’s Head honey mustard.

Notably sweet and rich in flavor, this honey mustard never fails to add some much-needed texture to your dish salads.

It works well with chicken and fries as well as all kinds of vegetables. 

This is the easiest way to add a deeper flavor note to your savory dinners, while still retaining that classic sweet honey flavor.

4. Stonewall Kitchen Sweet Honey Mustard

Check Current Price On Amazon

Another fantastic pick, we have the Stonewall Kitchen sweet honey mustard.

Incredibly tasty, delicious, and healthy, you would be hard-pressed to find a sauce that can even come close to this one.

There are several ways to use this sauce. It can be used as a marinade, a topping, or even as a dipping sauce. It is also worth mentioning that it works well with all types of meat as well as various kinds of vegetables. 

For instance, we highly recommend that you use it as a rub for your pork tenderloin. This is because it pairs well with the succulent texture of the meat, making it irresistible.

Of course, if you wish to go with lighter fare, then you would be glad to know that this sauce also works well with grilled street corn.

5. Woeber’s Reserve Honey Mustard

Check Current Price On Amazon

Another great honey mustard brand that deserves a spot on this list is Woeber. Made with quality ingredients, you will fall in love with its sweet and tangy mustard flavor.

It is certainly one of the most delicious brands around. This alone makes it the perfect sauce for whatever occasion. 

Incredibly versatile, feel free to use this honey mustard for your favorite appetizers and entrees.

Its rich and thick texture makes spreading and dipping incredibly convenient, so you won’t have to worry about making a mess. However, if we were to make a recommendation, Woeber is at its best when used on salads. 

6. Kraft Honey Mustard Dressing

Check Current Price On Amazon

Next, we have Kraft. This is one brand that needs no introduction. After all, it is a household name especially when it comes to condiments.

So, it is hardly surprising to find that their foray into the category of Honey Mustard has yielded exceptional results.

While primarily designed to be used as a dressing for your favorite salads, Kraft’s honey mustard is nothing if not versatile.

Not only is it great as a dressing, but it can also be used in several different ways. For instance, you can use it as a dipping sauce or as a marinade for chicken and fish. It even works well on sandwiches.

This is because Kraft’s Honey Mustard provides your dish with that distinctively sweet and tangy flavor that goes well with everything. The secret behind Kraft’s success is the high-quality ingredients that go into making this sauce.

As you take your first bite, you will immediately notice the overpowering flavors of honey mustard.

Take note that Kraft’s mixture of honey, Dijon mustard, and vinegar is what ultimately creates this memorable experience. You can’t help but feel your mouth watering with just a whiff.

If you are looking for something that breaks the mold yet delivers a familiar and enjoyable experience, then you need to try Kraft’s honey mustard dressing. 

7. Robert Rothschild Farm Raspberry Honey Mustard 

Check Current Price On Amazon

For our last pick, we thought we’d throw out a bit of an oddball idea. But trust us, this raspberry honey mustard is truly delicious!

One of the things that immediately stand out with this honey mustard dressing is that it is great all-around.

This means that whether you are in the mood for a sandwich, a burger, a hotdog, or even a pretzel, you can always rely on this raspberry honey mustard to give it that extra kick it needs.

A dollop of this sauce is good enough to do the job. This is because it boasts of a more intense flavor profile than other honey mustard dressings on this list, especially with the addition of the tart raspberry flavors!

Up Next: Chicken Wing Dipping Sauce (5 Tasty Recipes)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *