5 Best Gourmet Peanut Butters Of 2023

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

Peanut butter is one of those foods that just about everybody loves.

Of course, there are those who simply don’t care for peanut butter or can’t eat peanut butter and they are surely missing out. More for the rest of us to enjoy, right? 

Those who do enjoy using peanut butter find all sorts of uses for it. Some of us even just eat it with a spoon at times.

When it comes to peanut butter, you have your traditional brands that everyone knows, like Jif, Peter Pan, Skippy, and many more (we’re not picking favorites here!). Then, there is gourmet peanut butter. 

What is the best gourmet peanut butter? The best gourmet peanut butters are made with quality ingredients and usually avoid artificial or non-ethical preservatives and stabilizers, such as palm oil or any added sugars. A good gourmet peanut butter may also feature specialty flavors, like cookie dough or honey. 

In this guide, we will share with you the 5 best gourmet peanut butters out there. We’ve sorted through the options to really find the best. Our top picks are based on flavors as well as how they are made.

You really haven’t enjoyed peanut butter until you’ve tried a gourmet option so pay close attention! 

Stick with us to learn about the 5 best gourmet peanut butters and more! 

How To Choose A Gourmet Peanut Butter

What is it that makes a peanut butter a gourmet peanut butter in comparison to an everyday peanut butter?

In most cases, gourmet peanut butter is a natural peanut butter so it has fewer additives and ingredients and is simply made with the basics—peanuts and salt

There are other varieties of peanut butter but the thing to keep in mind is they use only the finest ingredients in the mix. 

This is not an exact science but it is a quality that typically sets them apart. Before you choose a gourmet peanut butter, take a look at these tips and considerations to help you choose the right one. 

What Exactly Is Gourmet Peanut Butter?

Gourmet peanut butter is all about the ingredients and the presentation. These are made with high-quality ingredients and the majority of the time they are also made with natural ingredients.

Some gourmet peanut butters have tons of flavor options while others are simple peanut butter that contains only peanuts and sea salt. 


Gourmet peanut butters might just be plain peanut butter or they might actually contain other flavors and additives.

You can certainly choose from a myriad of flavors but you also simply want to choose something that has good flavor.

You will see a variety of options and some of these contain a variety of ingredients. You should pay attention to the flavors involved and be sure it’s something you won’t turn your nose up at. 


Another thing that you will want to pay attention to is the ingredients. Any peanut butter could label themselves as gourmet if they want so don’t just be a sucker for a label.

Watch the ingredients and look at the source of the ingredients. You want to be sure that you’re getting what you pay for. 

Look for quality ingredients and make sure there aren’t any ingredients that you specifically want to avoid as well. Not all of these gourmet peanut butters are made the same and some of them have unique recipes. 

Smooth or Crunchy? 

Gourmet peanut butters are far more likely to have crunchy features but you can also find smooth options in the mix as well.

As you check out the options, be sure to keep in mind whether or not you prefer a smooth option or a crunchy option

This very well may be something specific that could make or break a decision for you so be sure to watch this detail, particularly if you have a preference on whether your peanut butter is crunchy or smooth. 

The 5 Best Gourmet Peanut Butters Of 2021

Now that you know a few key factors to consider, let’s get down to business. You will find that there is quite the variety of flavors and options out there.

We tried our very best to choose the top 5 from all of those options and we hope that you can find something here that you will enjoy. 

Below, you will find our top picks for the 5 best gourmet peanut butter options on the market. 

RankProductBest Feature
1.bNutty Gourmet Peanut Butter Gift PackBest overall gourmet peanut butter
2.Fix & Fogg Homestyle Smooth Peanut ButterUses dry roasted sea salt
3.Nuts ‘N More Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Peanut Butter SpreadChocolate chip cookie flavor
4.Wild Friends Foods Classic Creamy Peanut ButterDonates a percentage of their earnings to charity
5.Nutty Gourmet Honey Walnut ButterMade with honey and walnuts

1. bNutty Gourmet Peanut Butter Gift Pack

Check Current Price on Amazon

This first option for our top pick overall is this amazing variety pack.

It comes from one of the most well-known gourmet peanut butter brands out there.

These are absolutely awesome and they don’t have a single flavor we wouldn’t recommend. 

This option comes with 10 different flavors and it’s really a gift pack so each jar is 2 ounces of that specific flavor.

The pack comes with Crunchy, S’more, Salted Caramel, Blueberry, Toffee, Pretzel, Cinnamon Sugar Cookie, Cranberries, Coco-Nutty, and Skinny Dip

This gives you a really great variety, particularly if you want the ability to try several different flavor options. Then if you have a favorite, you can always go back and buy the full-sized jar of that flavor. 

These are made with natural peanut butter and there are no preservatives or anything like that in the mix. They are created in artisan batches and made in the USA. You won’t find better ingredients anywhere else. 


  • Gift pack of 10 different flavors
  • One of the most popular gourmet peanut butter brands
  • Made in the USA in small-batch processing
  • Made with all-natural ingredients
  • All of the ingredients are high-quality


  • These are only 2-ounce jars so they are pretty small and meant for testing in small doses

2. Fix & Fogg Homestyle Smooth Peanut Butter

Check Current Price on Amazon

If you’re looking for a gourmet peanut butter that is just simple and smooth, you will find it right here.

This peanut butter is made in New Zealand and it is delightful. It is perfectly smooth and made through a homestyle process.

They use dry roasted sea salt as well as golden peanuts. It has exceptional flavor but is incredibly simple at the same time. 

The peanut butter is rich and flavorful while also being healthy at the same time. All of the ingredients are natural and reliable. This is a full 13-ounce jar as well so you get plenty of peanut butter for the cost.

You will find that this peanut butter has no additives and no added sugar. It is free of palm oil, Non-GMO, and vegan-friendly as well.

This brand does have several other options for flavors, including a crunchy option or some specific flavor options as well if you decide you really like the brand. 


  • Smooth and delicious gourmet peanut butter
  • No additives and no sugar
  • Made with golden roasted peanuts plus sea salt
  • This brand has won multiple awards
  • Comes in a quality glass jar


  • The jar mouth is fairly small so it can sometimes be hard to mix the peanut butter

3. Nuts ‘N More Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough Peanut Butter Spread

Check Current Price on Amazon

Can you really get any better than peanut butter plus chocolate chip cookie dough?

This is a really awesome option and it’s designed to be a keto-friendly snack as well.

It’s low-carb, low-sugar, gluten-free, non-GMO, and completely all-natural. It has that delightful peanut butter flavor as well as chocolate chip cookie dough added to it. 

The company describes this peanut butter as “so good you’ll wanna eat it right off the spoon!” and we have to agree.

It’s a quality high-protein peanut butter with delicious flavor. It does have actual chocolate chips in it as well and absolutely nothing artificial. 

If you look at the ingredients list, it’s really pretty simple. They of course use peanuts and other natural ingredients, including a natural sweetener. The majority of the ingredients are for the cookie dough addition.

If you like the sound of this brand but you’re not sure you like this flavor, they have a ton of other flavors too—including birthday cake and even banana nut. 


  • Designed to be a healthy, high-protein peanut butter
  • Very good flavor
  • Made with quality ingredients
  • Several flavor options to choose from
  • Loaded with nutrition and gourmet design


  • Considering the claims for a healthy option, this is fairly high on the calorie scale per serving 
  • The texture is slightly gritty

4. Wild Friends Foods Classic Creamy Peanut Butter

Check Current Price on Amazon

Here is another creamy option that is simple and delicious all at the same time.

It doesn’t have any added flavors or crunchy additions. It’s just a simple classic, creamy peanut butter.

The brand does offer some flavor choices so that is an option here if it appeals to you more. 

Wild Friends uses peanuts sourced directly from Georgia that are double-ground for the mix.

They do not use any palm oil and they stand as an ethical company as well. This is a charitable company as well, with them donating a percentage of their earnings to women and girls. 

This peanut butter is made with all-natural ingredients. It contains just roasted peanuts as well as sea salt and nothing else in the creamy blend. It’s free of palm oil but there will be oil in the mix from natural separation.

It is also considered to be non-GMO as well as gluten-free since it is a natural peanut butter. 


  • Simple creamy peanut butter
  • All-natural with just two ingredients
  • They do have other flavor options available
  • Peanuts are double ground for smooth texture
  • You get 3 jars of peanut butter for this price


  • This peanut butter is very thin which may limit some of its uses slightly

5. Nutty Gourmet Honey Walnut Butter

Check Current Price on Amazon

This last option is a classic peanut butter combination. We personally love peanut butter and honey sandwiches!

They are so delicious and this peanut butter combines peanut butter and honey to bring you the best of both worlds.

It has just a light amount of honey to sweeten it but not so much that it’s overwhelming in the flavor. 

This peanut butter is made with walnuts instead of peanuts so it also has a bit of a changed flavor from that and it’s really good!

You will find that the ingredients list is pretty simple, although the honey granules do contain cane sugar. This also contains sustainable palm oil. 

It’s a natural and quality choice, made with gourmet ingredients. The flavor really stands out in the market of gourmet peanut butters.


  • Uses walnuts instead of peanuts
  • Combines the perfect flavors of peanut butter and honey
  • A quality choice with quality ingredients
  • Made by a family with locally sourced ingredients
  • Peanut-free option for peanut butter


  • This does tend to be very oily, which may cause some problems with spreading

Related Questions

We hope that you find this guide to the very best gourmet peanut butters on the market to be a valuable resource for helping you find a peanut butter option to try.

There are many really great options out there and a flavor for every preference as well. 

We invite you to take a look at the following question and answer section for some additional details that may be helpful to you as well. 

What makes a peanut butter gourmet? 

Gourmet peanut butters can really fall into a vast category. So what is it that really sets them apart? Ultimately, gourmet in this sense means that quality ingredients are used and that presentation matters

When it comes to gourmet peanut butter, you will find that there are many different flavor combinations and options as well as the traditional smooth and creamy peanut butter in the category as well.

Ultimately, what makes them gourmet is the quality of the ingredients more than anything else. 

Is gourmet peanut butter healthy?

Typically, gourmet peanut butter is healthier than other peanut butter options.

You will find that most brands avoid using sugar (although some do have sugar) but they use quality ingredients and often use all-natural ingredients as well. 

This may not be true of every single peanut butter labeled as gourmet so it’s always a good idea to look at the labels and ingredients to determine.

Does gourmet peanut butter have to be flavored? 

Absolutely not! There are plenty of gourmet peanut butter options out there that are simple smooth or crunchy peanut butter.

They are gourmet because of how they are made. Of course, there are also a ton of flavor options out there and most of them are very good if you’re willing to give them a try. 

Up Next: What Is Chicken Bouillon?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *