The Best Neufchatel Cheese Substitutes
Neufchatel cheese, both French and American, is not very popular and widely available. Thus, it is good to know a few substitutes for Neufchatel cheese in case the recipe calls for it and you can’t find it at your local supermarket.
What are the best Neufchatel cheese substitutes? The best substitute for American Neufchatel is cream cheese due to their nearly identical makeup aside from the presence of cream in cream cheese. Depending on the recipe, you can also substitute Neufchatel cheese with cottage cheese, ricotta, mascarpone, cashew cheese, and farmer’s cheese.
Continue reading to learn what Neufchatel cheese is and what makes it similar to cream cheese that we all use and love. You will also learn about other substitutes for Neufchatel suitable for various cooking tasks.
Neufchatel Cheese – Origin and Uses
Neufchatel cheese is one of the oldest French cheese varieties. It originated in the 6th century in Neufchâtel-en-Bray, a commune in Northern France.
Neufchatel is made of raw cow’s milk and is a soft and crumbly cheese variety. The cheese has an edible white rind similar to that of Camembert.
Neufchatel, however, is saltier than Camembert and sharper. The salty flavor of this cheese variety is developed after 6-10 weeks of maturing.
The inside of Neufchatel cheese is soft and spreadable. Neufchatel often comes shaped like a heart. It can also be produced in log or square forms.
French Vs American Neufchatel
There is an American version of this refined French cheese variety. In the late 19th century, American dairyman William Lawrence added cream to the original French recipe for Neufchatel cheese.
Adding the cream to the milk resulted in the American version of Neuchatel cheese that is similar to cream cheese.
However, American Neufchatel is softer than regular cream cheese, with a lower fat content and a high amount of moisture in the cheese.
Another difference between American and French Neufchatel cheese is that American Neufchatel is made from pasteurized milk while French Neufchatel is made from raw milk.
French and American Neufchatel differ texture-wise too. True French Neufchatel is a soft-ripened cheese that has a firm and slightly crumbly texture when fully ripened. American Neufchatel is soft and spreadable and looks like cream cheese.
Uses of Neufchatel Cheese
It is best to enjoy French Neufchatel with toasted bread and a glass of wine.
However, French Neufchatel does melt and you can use it to make salads, omelets, as well as top pizza.
As for American Neufchatel, it is similar to cream cheese and people often use it as a low-calorie alternative to cream cheese. You can use American Neuchatel to make pasta, cheese ball, dips, cheese frosting, etc.
Can You Substitute Neufchatel Cheese?
French Neufchatel cheese is not as widely available as many other cheese varieties. American Neufchatel, on the other hand, can be found in many American stores.
But if you fail to find American Neufchatel cheese, you can choose from the multiple alternatives it has. Luckily, there are other cheese varieties that can be used to replace Neufchatel cheese.
What Are the Best Neuchatel Cheese Substitutes?
There are multiple Neufchatel cheese substitutes that you can use for various cooking tasks. The key is picking the right alternative for the particular dish you are making.
| Rank | Substitute | Why It Works | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Cream cheese | Similar flavor and texture | Cheesecake, frosting, pasta, dips, baked goods |
| 2. | Cottage cheese | Neutral flavor | Toppings and dips |
| 3. | Ricotta | Similar texture | Pancakes, cheesecake, pasta |
| 4. | Mascarpone | Similar texture | Desserts |
| 5. | Cashew cheese | Similar flavor | Sauces, pasta, pizza |
| 6. | Farmer’s cheese | Mild flavor | Topping for toast, dips |
Cream Cheese – The Best Neufchatel Cheese Substitute
Cream cheese is the best substitute for American Neufchatel cheese. The two are interchangeable in nearly all recipes.
In fact, these two cheese varieties are so similar that you might not be to tell them apart if you saw American Neufchatel and cream cheese side-by-side out of their packaging.
Let’s see how Neufchatel and cream cheese compare.
Flavor
The flavor of American Neufchatel is very comparable to the flavor of cream cheese. Both are tangy and milky, with American Neufchatel tasting slightly richer according to some people.
As for French Neufchatel, its flavor is well-developed thanks to the weeks of ripening. Many describe French Neufchatel as having notes and aroma of mushrooms.
In this respect, French Neufchatel is similar to another cheese from Normandy, Camembert. This popular French cheese variety with a similar appearance to French Neufchatel has mushroomy notes too.
Contents
As French Neufchatel is made from milk and cream cheese is made from milk and cream, the latter has a much higher fat and water content.
Cream cheese contains 33% milk fat and moisture content up to 55%. Milk fat in French Neufchatel is around 23%.
Milk fat in American Neufchatel, though there is still cream in it, is also lower than in regular cream cheese.
So, American Neufchatel is slightly healthier than cream cheese. If you are trying to lower the fat content in your dishes, you should certainly try substituting cream cheese with Neufchatel in some recipes.
Texture
The texture of traditionally made French Neufchatel cheese doesn’t compare to the texture of regular cream cheese. French Neufchatel is spreadable yet grainy, with a velvety rind all around it.
As for American Neufchatel, it is quite similar to cream cheese as both are soft, dense, and spreadable. With this being said, many find American Neufchatel to be a tad bit more granular than cream cheese.
The texture differences of these cheese varieties come from the techniques used to manufacture them. Unlike Neufchatel, cream cheese contains stabilizers and is firmed with lactic acid.
Cheese manufacturers use guar gum, a stabilizer and thickening agent, to reach the desired texture for cream cheese. Without these additives, cream cheese would be crumbly too.
Uses
You can replace American Neufchatel with cream cheese in nearly all recipes. Cream cheese is best used for cheesecakes, frostings, baked goods, dips, sauces, as a topping for sandwiches and toasted bread, pasta, etc.
Other Substitutes
In the majority of the cases, cream cheese is an ideal substitute for Neufchatel cheese. But sometimes you may want to go out of the cream cheese family for one reason or another. Fortunately, there are multiple options to choose from.
While these Neufchatel substitutes are not as versatile as cream cheese and may not work for all recipes that call for American Neufchatel, you can still find an option that will work well for the occasion.
When choosing a Neufchatel substitute, pay attention to its contents, texture, and flavor.
Cottage Cheese
Cottage cheese doesn’t have a texture similar to American Neufchatel. However, you can blend cottage cheese and it will turn into a great alternative to Neufchatel.
To turn grainy cottage cheese into a smooth alternative to Neufchatel you will need to blend it with equal parts of half-and-half.
This will add up the calories but the texture will be on point. Butter or margarine will also work if you don’t have half-and-half at hand.
Cottage cheese has a mild neutral flavor and a lower fat content compared to cream cheese or American Neufchatel.
Ricotta
Ricotta is an Italian substitute for the American Neufchatel cheese. It is a whey cheese made from sheep, goat, or buffalo milk. You can also buy ricotta cheese made from cow’s milk.
The texture of ricotta cheese is similar to that of American Neufchatel. Ricotta is thick, smooth but also somewhat grainy as it is whey cheese.
The flavor is light, with a small amount of salt. This makes ricotta suitable for a range of cooking tasks.
You can use ricotta to make pancakes, bake a cheesecake, add it to pasta dishes, use it as a stuffing for various dishes, etc.
Mascarpone
If you are looking for a substitute for American Neufchatel or cream cheese for desserts, use mascarpone.
This Italian cream cheese has a rich and creamy texture. But there are flavor differences between mascarpone and American Neufchatel which make mascarpone an alternative for Neufchatel only for certain recipes.
As opposed to the tangy flavor of Neufchatel, mascarpone is sweet, with a high amount of saturated fat. This makes mascarpone a good option for desserts.
Cashew Cheese
Some people describe the flavor of French Neufchatel as nutty and yeasty. If you are looking for a substitute reminiscent to French Neufchatel in terms of flavor but closer to American Neufchatel in terms of texture, then cashew cheese it is.
Cashew cheese contains raw cashews and nutritional yeast. It is a great option for vegans and vegetarians. Cashew cheese is delicious, and what’s even more important, you can easily make it at home.
Farmer’s Cheese
If you are missing all of the abovementioned substitutes for Neufchatel, you can try using farmer’s cheese instead if it suits the dish you are making.
Farmer’s cheese is fresh unripened cottage cheese with a mild flavor and grainy texture. You can use it as a topping for toasted bread or salads. It can also be used to make cheesecakes.
Up Next: 3 Best Hot Honeys
