Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – How To Choose

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

Mountain Dew and Mello Yello are two citrus-flavored soft drinks that do a great job of quenching your thirst on a hot summer day!

The two soft drinks do seem very similar to each other, especially when it comes to appearance, flavor, and taste, but they are different drinks and need to be appreciated as such!

How do you choose between Mountain Dew and Mello Yello?

It really will be up to personal taste whether you choose Mello Yello or Mountain Dew, but knowing the differences between them can definitely help with this.

For example, Mountain Dew contains more sugar than Mello Yello, which could be a deciding factor for you.

To help you choose between the two citrus soft drinks, read on to find out more information about each!

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – Taste

can of mello yello

When choosing a soft drink to enjoy, one of the most important factors would be taste!

You would choose a drink that you think tastes better than the other, so looking at the taste differences between the two is important.

Both sodas have a citrus flavor to them, as they are both citrus-based drinks. However, Mountain Dew contains more sugar than Mello Yello, so it has a much sweeter taste to it.

Mountain Dew also contains more citric acid, so it has a more lemon-focused taste.

Mello Yello is less sweet than Mountain Dew, although it is still fairly sweet. It has more of an orange-citrus flavor, as it contains a small amount of real orange juice.

Both drinks are fizzy and tangy, and wonderfully refreshing. For a sweeter, more lemony flavor, opt for Mountain Dew, but for a slightly less sweet, more orangey flavor, Mello Yello would be the better option

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – Appearance

It is always better to have the drink you’re enjoying match its flavor, and Mountain Dew and Mello Yello do exactly this. 

Both Mountain Dew and Mello Yello have a very similar appearance, and when poured into clear glasses, it is nearly impossible to tell them apart.

Both have an added yellow coloring to them, which gives them a translucent, yellow color, with some bubbles from the fizz.

The sodas taste exactly how they look, and there is really no difference between them when it comes to appearance!

The only difference in appearance is with the bottles and labeling, as they are two different brand packaging with different labels.

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – Caffeine Content

For many, the caffeine content of a soda is a make-or-break factor. This is especially true if you are sharing the soda with your family, as you do not want your kids drinking a soda that has high caffeine content.

Both Mountain Dew and Mello Yello have fairly high caffeine content, with both soft drinks containing more caffeine than both Pepsi and Coca-Cola.

There isn’t much difference between the caffeine content in Mountain Dew and Mello Yello. Mountain Dew contains around 51 mg of caffeine in a regular can, whereas Mello Yello contains around 54 mg of caffeine in a regular can.

So Mello Yello has slightly more caffeine than Mountain Dew, but it is a very small difference.

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – Variety

It is always good to have a few options and variety with your favorite beverage. Both Mountain Dew and Mello Yello are available in a few different varieties, giving you more choice when picking out which one to drink.

Mountain Dew has a diet counterpart, which is supposed to be lower in sugar.

There are also different Mountain Dew flavors available, such as orange, melon, citrus, grape, and raspberry.

Mello Yello, like Mountain Dew, comes in a diet or no-sugar option. Other Mello Yello flavor options include cherry, melon, grape, peach, orange, raspberry peach, citrus twist, strawberry orange, and a few more.

Mello Yello does have more variety of flavor, so if you are looking to mix things up every once in a while, it might be the better option for you.

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – Packaging

It might seem boring, but it is worth knowing the various packaging sizes that both have, so you can better know your options when buying your favorite soda!

Mountain Dew and Mello Yello both come in a variety of different sizes, so there is quite a bit of choice for each.

Mountain Dew is available in 16 oz and 20 oz sizes, as well as bigger bottle sizes in some stores. You can also purchase the cans or bottles in multipacks if you want to stock up.

Mello Yello is available in 16 oz, 20 oz, and 24 oz sizes, and can also be purchased in multipacks so you never run out!

Whether you want to enjoy a can of soda on your own or purchase a bigger bottle to share with family or friends, there is an option for each!

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – Ingredients

The ingredients used to make Mountain Dew and Mello Yello are fairly similar, but there are a few differences to take note of.

Mello Yello is made with: carbonated water, concentrated orange juice, high fructose corn syrup, citric acid, sodium benzoate, natural flavors, carob bean gum, potassium citrate, erythorbic acid, caffeine, and coloring yellow 5.

Mountain Dew is made with: carbonated water, high-fructose corn syrup, citric acid, concentrated orange juice, sodium benzoate, natural flavors, caffeine, sodium citrate, gum arabic, erythorbic acid, calcium disodium, brominated vegetable oil, and yellow 5.

These ingredients might not mean much to you, but there are some people who need to avoid certain ingredients.

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – Ownership

While it will not affect the flavor or enjoyment of the drink, some people are very loyal to certain brands, so it might make a difference for you, to know where the soda originates from.

Mello Yello is a soda owned and produced by the Coca-Cola company, whereas Mountain Dew is owned and produced by PepsiCo. 

Mello Yello and Mountain Dew are considered to be rival citrus-flavored drinks, mainly because PepsiCo and Coca-Cola are two of the biggest soda rivals around!

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – Which Is Better?

There is no way we could say whether Mountain Dew or Mello Yello is better, as this would depend on your taste preferences more than anything else.

However, we can give you some advice on which one to choose if you have not tasted either before.

If you are looking for the better of the two options when it comes to a lower sugar content, then Mello Yello would be the better option. It also contains more natural orange juice than Mountain Dew.

On the other hand, Mountain Dew is sweeter, which could be what you prefer. It is America’s favorite citrus soda, and for good reason, so it is definitely worth a try.

Many people consider Mello Yello to be more orange-tasting, and Mountain Dew to be more lemon-tasting, so this might also sway your preference one way or the other.

Both come in a wide variety of flavors, and both have a diet option to choose from as well, so there are many options to choose from.

Another factor worth noting is that Mountain Dew is made by PepsiCo, whereas Mello Yello is made by the Coca-Cola Company.

Mountain Dew was the original citrus soda on the market, with Mello Yello following a few decades later as a rival.

Mountain Dew Vs Mello Yello – How To Choose

Take a read through all of the above differences between Mountain Dew and Mello Yello, to work out which one you should choose.

It is difficult to describe the taste and quality of a soda drink, especially between two which are as similar as Mountain dew and Mello Yello, so we actually recommend trying out both, and then deciding which one you prefer from there!

Both Mello Yello and Mountain Dew are citrus-flavored sodas, with Mountain Dew being the most popular of the two, and you definitely cannot go wrong with either on a hot summer’s day, when a cold, refreshing soda is exactly what you need!

Related Questions

Is Mello Yello healthier than Mountain Dew?

Mello Yello contains less sugar than Mountain Dew, but this does not necessarily mean that it is healthy. Both of these citrus sodas contain a very high amount of sugar, to balance out the tangy citrus flavor that they have.

The sugar content in both is higher than most other sodas, which is something to consider before gulping one down.

Which soda is similar to Mountain Dew?

Other than Mello Yello, a soda that is most similar to Mountain Dew is Mountain Lion. It contains roughly the same amount of sugar and caffeine, with the same citrus flavor too.

What is the most popular Mountain Dew flavor?

The most popular Mountain Dew flavor would have to be the original flavor. Following closely behind would be Baja Blast, Code Red, Raspberry Lemonade, and Voltage.

While the other flavor options might be popular, they will never overtake the popularity of Original Mountain Dew

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *