The 7 Best Yorkshire Pudding Tins Of 2024
Yorkshire pudding is the perfect side for that big family dinner you prepare.
We can see it now: A delicious roasted chicken graces the table. There’s roasted carrots and onions with whole cloves of garlic on a plate. The meal only needs a Yorkshire pudding to top it all off!
These delicious side additions have changed since their origination many, many years ago but they are no less delicious.
If you’re going to make Yorkshire pudding, then you need a reliable tin to take care of the job!
What is the best Yorkshire pudding tin? Traditional tins have 4 shallow sections in them but you can choose other options as well. Ultimately, you can use your choice of tin to make Yorkshire pudding but you will need to make sure that it can stand up to the heat. Non-stick materials are a good choice.
In this guide, we will share with you the 7 best Yorkshire pudding tins on the market. We’ve narrowed down the options to bring you the very best. We made an attempt to offer a variety of options so you can certainly find something to meet your needs.
Keep reading to learn about the best Yorkshire pudding tins and more!
How to Choose the Best Yorkshire Pudding Tin
One thing we know for certain is that no product is ever made equally across the board. There are various brands, sizes, and styles of just about anything you can purchase.
So what do you choose?
We’ve put together a simple buyer’s guide to help give you some tips on things that you may want to consider as you look through your options and make a decision on the best tin for your Yorkshire pudding!
And if all sorts of puddings from Europe are some of your favorite foods, why not also check out our list of the 7 best steam pudding molds?
Size & Servings
First things first. How many servings do you want to be able to make in a single tin?
Remember that a traditional tin will have four shallow sections but you could use other tins that will allow you to make multiple puddings at one time.
Sometimes a high-quality muffin pan with shallow sections (such as those provided for muffin tops) is a great choice, even though it’s not technically meant for Yorkshire pudding. This may mean you end up with 6 or more sections or “cups.”
There are also tins that let you make a single pudding if you prefer to dish it out according to desired serving size.
The size and the number of servings you want to be able to make are completely up to you. As you make a selection, we recommend that you take this thought into consideration so that you can get the best item to meet your needs.
Materials
The materials can certainly make a significant difference when it comes to Yorkshire pudding.
You want a sturdy and durable tin but you also don’t want it to be overly heavy or bulky to work with. Try to find something that falls somewhere in the middle so you don’t end up with something flimsy either.
Consider the material the tin was made with and the quality of that material. You might even want to check out what other buyers are saying so you know if the tin will meet your expectations.
Non-Stick Coating
Using a non-stick tin can be very helpful when it comes to Yorkshire pudding. You want your pudding to easily slip out of the tin when you are ready to serve it. If it sticks and tears up, it becomes a nuisance.
Let’s not even talk about how hard it may be to clean a pan once your Yorkshire pudding has stuck to it. Not only did it ruin the look of your dish, but it also makes washing it a major chore.
Completion of Yorkshire Pudding
Most of the time, Yorkshire pudding is made in a fairly shallow tin. This is just the nature of the dish.
You can, however, work with regular muffin tins if you prefer. Just be aware that they are deeper than the typical Yorkshire tin. A better alternative, as we said before, would be a pan designed for muffin tops, as these are more shallow in design.
In the end, you want your Yorkshire pudding to cook evenly throughout the pan. You don’t want to notice a difference on the edge slots or the center slots compared to the others.
You want your Yorkshire pudding to come out light and crisp, while also being able to hold gravy. You don’t want them to fall apart when you remove them from the pan. And you definitely want any leftovers to hold up when reheated!
Keeping these goals in mind can help you pick the right pan, giving you the best Yorkshire pudding!
The 7 Best Yorkshire Pudding Tins
Whether you want to make a traditional Yorkshire pudding or you want to give it your own twist, choosing the right tin for your needs is very important. Remember to choose something with shallow cups to get it just right!
Below you will find our top 7 picks for the best Yorkshire pudding tins:
| Rank | Product | Key Features |
|---|---|---|
| 1. | Kitchencraft Masterclass Yorkshire Pudding Tin | Non-stick, 4-cup |
| 2. | Chicago Metallic Muffin Top Pan | Non-stick, 6-cup |
| 3. | Mermaid Yorkshire Pudding Tin | Stainless steel, 13" |
| 4. | Walfos Texas Muffin Pan | Silicone, 6-cup |
| 5. | CasaWare Jumbo Muffin Pan | Non-stick, 6-cup |
| 6. | Dexam Yorkshire Pudding Tin | Steel, 12-cup |
| 7. | Judge Yorkshire Pudding Tin | Steel, 4-cup |
We’ve also got more on each of these fabulous tins, so be sure to keep reading for more on these top options.
1. Kitchencraft Masterclass Yorkshire Pudding Tin
Let’s start off our list of the best tins with a traditional style. This pan design represents those from the old days when Yorkshire puddings were first created – or at least something like it! When the first tin was designed for Yorkshire pudding, this was the general original design.
This option from Kitchencraft is a great choice. It’s a heavy-duty pan that isn’t overly heavy. It is a non-stick pan as well. The holes in this pan are perfectly shallow and just deep enough to make the perfect pudding.
The pan has rolled edges to make it sturdy without being heavy. The materials are thick carbon steel that won’t warp or bend. It is rust-resistant and also has a flawless non-stick release that won’t let you down.
This brand is top-notch and they offer a 20-year guarantee on their products. The pan is freezer, fridge, and dishwasher safe as well.
Pros:
- High-quality tin
- Perfect depth of cups/holes
- Non-stick coating that truly works
- Sturdy and durable
- 20-year product guarantee
Cons:
- If you’re not careful, you will scratch the non-stick coating. Be sure to use the right utensils.
2. Chicago Metallic Muffin Top Pan
If you want an option that can hold a little bit more, this is a great selection. Chicago Metallic presents a tin with 6 shallow holes. Although it’s designed with muffin tops in mind, it’s perfect for making Yorkshire pudding. This is a budget-friendly choice and still of great quality as well.
This tin is made with premium quality carbon steel that is a heavy weight for durability but not overly heavy for comfort. It is a non-stick pan and it provides awesome heat conduction over the entire pan length.
The non-stick coating works beautifully. The pan is rated as dishwasher-safe, which is certainly a bonus. However, hand-washing is still recommended to maintain the life of the pan overall.
Pros:
- Perfect size pan for multiple puddings
- Dishwasher-safe materials
- Made with premium materials
- Makes 6 puddings at a time
- Non-stick coating
Cons:
- The coating is not consistent quality and may start to flake or peel.
3. Mermaid Yorkshire Pudding Tin
This next option brings you a whole different outlook on a Yorkshire pudding pan. Rather than having shallow slots for your individual pieces, this is a single rectangular pan. You can make one large pudding, which is a popular way to make Yorkshire pudding as well.
This pan comes with a lifetime guarantee. The materials are awesome. It is a bit more expensive but we think you will find the quality is well worth the cost. This pan is heavy-duty. It is made with anodized aluminum, making it sturdy and durable.
You will find that heat distributes evenly throughout the pan and your Yorkshire pudding will come out great! The pan is oven-safe to extreme temperatures, even up to 470 degrees! It measures 13L x 11W x 2 1/4D. It’s comparable to a casserole pan size.
Pros:
- Large, single pan
- Made with durable materials
- Covered by a lifetime guarantee
- Distributes heat evenly
- Oven-safe to 470 degrees Fahrenheit
Cons:
- Materials are not dishwasher-safe.
- Not a non-stick pan but it will adapt over time with seasoning.
4. Walfos Texas Muffin Pan
Here is another really great option! This Yorkshire pudding tin is actually a silicone mold that is food-safe and BPA-free.
We like to give a bit of variety. While this is a silicone mold, it is perfectly sized as far as depth goes to make your Yorkshire pudding just right.
The silicone makes this pan easy to use and also makes it easy to remove things when they are finished cooking. It’s a non-stick material s you shouldn’t have any issues getting your cooked pudding out.
There are 6 shallow spaces for your Yorkshire pudding. The silicone is flexible and easy to wash when you’re done. This silicone is safe for the oven up to 446 degrees, which should be plenty. Plus, you don’t have to worry about losing your non-stick coating or rusting!
Pros:
- Non-stick coating never comes off
- Easy to use and wash
- Flexible material makes it versatile
- Perfect sizes for Yorkshire pudding
- High-quality materials
Cons:
- The silicone material does make it flimsy so you may need a baking sheet underneath for support.
5. CasaWare Jumbo Muffin Pan
Ok, we know that says muffin pan but hear us out! This “muffin pan” makes a really great option for Yorkshire pudding.
It’s a bit deeper than traditional pudding pans but not so deep that it doesn’t work well. It allows you a little more space to fill but is still really a perfect size overall.
This is a unique pan. It’s fairly heavy but still easy to handle. It is made with a ceramic coating that gives it just a little something extra.
You can get it in a silver granite color or a blue or red that have the granite ‘look’ also. Style may not be what’s most important in baking, but it never hurts either!
The ceramic coating is non-stick and very easy to wipe clean but it offers a higher functionality overall for your cooking process.
This coating can handle temperatures up to 450 degrees and won’t peel or blister. These holes are 1.75 inches deep, which is pretty great and you can make 6 at a time.
Pros:
- Gorgeous granite-style finish
- Ceramic coating can handle high temperatures
- Makes 6 Yorkshire puddings at a time
- Non-stick coating that slides right off
- Heavy-duty build and design
Cons:
- Hand washing is recommended with a gentle process.
- The slots are deeper than most tins but will work OK.
6. Dexam Yorkshire Pudding Tin
We couldn’t go any further without giving you a deluxe edition option for your Yorkshire pudding tin. When we say deluxe edition, we mean that you can make 12 puddings at a time!
It’s pretty awesome and gives you the versatility to make them in bulk if you need to.
This is a non-stick pan that is well-made. The materials are sturdy and durable, made with heavy-duty steel to really last. The steel doesn’t make it heavy, it’s actually very light without being flimsy.
You cannot put this in the dishwasher, you will need to wash it by hand. The puddings will slide out seamlessly and easily so the entire thing makes it to your plate without sticking to the pan. We love the versatility and size of this pan. It’s perfect for Yorkshire pudding.
Pros:
- Durable pan made of steel
- Non-stick coating
- Designed to make 12 puddings at once
- Lightweight without being flimsy
- Premium materials and quality
Cons:
- The pan could potentially bend or misshape easily if it is mishandled.
7. Judge Yorkshire Pudding Tin
For our final selection, we share with you another traditional 4-hole Yorkshire pudding pan that is a great buy. This features the classic style in a pan designed for this particular English dish. It’s a top-rated pan and it’s pretty awesome in quality.
This pan is made with heavy-duty steel. The edges are rolled to give the pan a bit more durability and stability so it’s not flimsy when you lift. The pan is even dishwasher-safe, which is always a plus!
This pan comes with a non-stick guarantee that is expected to last for at least 5 years. The whole pan is then covered by a 25-year quality guarantee for the pan. This speaks a little about the quality and reliability of the pan overall.
The edges are not designed for a sturdy grip, despite the rolled edges. You may need to consider using a rack or baking sheet underneath it for easier handling.
Pros:
- This pan was designed for Yorkshire pudding and works great
- High-quality and reliable materials
- The pan is durable and has a 25-year guarantee
- Traditional-style pan
- Non-stick coating
Cons:
- Getting a good grip on this pan can be a challenge.
- Very lightweight and could move while filling if you aren’t careful.
Conclusion
In review, keep in mind that you want to choose the pan that will work most for your needs.
Do you need something that will make 12 Yorkshire puddings, for example, or would you prefer to stick with the traditional 4-serving tin?
Make sure you select a tin based not only on the style but also on the ability to deliver to your needs. This is one of the most important things to keep in mind as you pick out a pan. Your needs and preferences do matter!
Happy baking!
Up Next: Bread Pudding Without Oven
