9 Best Toasters For Sourdough Bread Of 2023

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

Sourdough bread slices are typically longer and wider than regular bread which is why if you want perfectly toasted slices, then you have to get the right toaster for the job! 

What are the best toasters for sourdough bread? Sourdough bread toasters have a larger and wider input slot where any artisanal bread slice can fit. These toasters are specially designed to toast the slice on each side without causing it to warm up unevenly or even char or burn! 

Read below to learn more about these special toasters and how you can use them for homemade sourdough bread, and the best sourdough toaster recommendations for all types of uses! 

Sourdough Bread And Toasters

Most toasters can fit sourdough slices, but with a huge exception: nearly all of them will require you to force the bread inside!

Sourdough bread is longer and wider than a usual loaf of bread and while it may not be as dense, it requires a bit more space to adequately toast on each side.

Forcing the wider bread slice inside a small toaster can ruin its texture and shape, not to mention, it may also cause an excess of crumbs to collect at the bottom of the toaster which can become a nightmare to clean! 

In theory, any toaster with a large enough slot can be used to warm up a delicious slice of sourdough. but if you want the most out of the flavor and texture of the bread, we recommend investing in an appropriate appliance. 

Bakery toasters, designed for sourdough and other types of artisanal bread products, have an input slot of at least 10″ x 1.5″, which should be more than enough for any type of airy bread loaf

However, the width of the bread also depends on where you purchase it from.

Everyone has a different opinion on the appropriate thickness level of sourdough bread but almost everyone can agree that it is usually wider and longer than a typical wheat bread! 

How Is Sourdough Bread Different? 

What makes sourdough bread require a special toaster and why is it usually airier and arguably better than regular wheat bread? Well, to answer this question, we will have to rewind the clock to a few hundred years. 

See, back in the day, every bread was considered to be a type of sourdough bread, meaning that it was made using just a simple combination of flour, salt, and water. 

Now, you might be wondering why we didn’t mention yeast in the list of ingredients!

Commercial yeast, the kind that is used worldwide for bread making, is a relatively recent invention that was inaccessible for most of humanity’s early bread-making years. 

Bread makers relied on the naturally occurring yeast and processes that resulted from mixing the aforementioned ingredients

It is said that the earliest attempts to make bread resulted in a denser and firmer bread loaf.

Eventually, though, it was the bread makers in Egypt that first discovered that if a mixture of flour and water was left to ferment in specific conditions, it would result in a much airier and softer bread.

This new type of bread was vastly different from the leavened flatbread that was being consumed up until that point in time—and thus, the basis for sourdough bread was formed, and we have never looked back since!

Sourdough bread is made using a natural “starter culture” that is derived from mixing and fermenting water and flour. 

The catch here is that the starter culture needs to be “fed” with fresh water and flour regularly to keep it alive.

Starter cultures can be months or even several years old. This extra time adds superior biodiversity to the loaf and produces an arguably better bread product. 

In fact, this biodiversity is one of the reasons why sourdough bread has a distinct and slightly tangy flavor. The friendly bacteria present in the culture lend to the flavor of the bread and make it airier and softer! 

Compared to regular bread, which is made using concentrated yeast, sourdough can be easier to digest and is generally considered to be a healthier option too.

Commercial yeast is an excellent ingredient for conveniently making bread but it has its drawbacks: For instance, instant yeast or similar yeast products fast-track the fermentation process which results in an incomplete breakdown of flour. 

Sure, the bread comes out looking fresh and soft but most commercial bread products contain a long list of ingredients that include preservatives, bread improvers, and enhancers. 

Whereas with sourdough, you would be astonished by just how little goes into making this bread, and yet, this method produces a much better loaf!

Making Sourdough Bread  

We believe that making sourdough bread is an absolute necessity, especially if you are an avid bread consumer. The reason for this is simple: commercial sourdough bread may not be “sourdough” at all. 

It turns out that some manufactured sourdough bread may contain additional yeast and improvers to make the bread taste “better”. If you ask us, this is a direct violation of what sourdough bread stands for! 

Sourdough bread is easy to make and you can get a much better and more personalized bread, one that even toasts well, at home rather than relying on the usual subpar commercial variety. 

Here is how to make foolproof sourdough bread at home:


  • 50-100 g (1⁄4 – 1/2 cup) – active starter
  • 375 g (1 1/2 cups plus 1 tbsp) warm water
  • 500 g (4 cups plus 2 tbsp) bread flour
  • 9-12 g (1.5 – 2.5 teaspoons) fine sea salt


  1. In a large bowl, mix the starter culture and water, and then add flour and salt. Mix to combine until a dough starts to form. Cover the bowl and let it rest for about 30 minutes.
  2. Once the dough has risen, grab a corner of the dough and gently pull it up and bring it back to the middle of the dough. The idea here is to stretch and knead the dough so that it becomes softer and more textured when baked. Repeat this step at least 2-4 times (with 30-minute intervals). If you don’t have the time then you can only do this step once or twice. Each stretch and pull will benefit the dough! 
  3. Cover the dough and let it rest for about 8 hours at 70°F. You may want to keep the bowl at a lower temperature if you already live in a hot environment. 
  4. After the 8-hour mark, check the dough for signs of doneness. By now, the dough would have either doubled in size or risen to about 50%. Either condition is acceptable. We have found that the 50% risen dough has a better spring to it when baked than the double-sized dough, but you can choose either option as per your preference. 
  5. Shape the dough by forming it into a rounded flat ball and then let it rest for another 30 minutes. In the meantime, prepare a proofing bowl by lining it with a clean towel and lightly dusting the surface of the bowl and towel with flour. 
  6. Shape the dough as indicated in step 5 one last time before moving it into the lined bowl. Cover the dough and refrigerate it for at least 1-2 hours. 
  7. While the dough is proofed for a final time, prepare the oven by preheating it to 550°F along with a baking pot. 
  8. Once the dough has been proofed. Move the prepared dough to the preheated pot and using the tip of a razor blade, carefully and gently make an incision in the shape of an “X” on top
  9. Lower the temperature to 420°F and bake for 45 minutes or until golden brown! 

Toasting Sourdough 

Now that you know how to make sourdough, it’s time to toast it the right way!

Sourdough bread, especially one that is baked fresh is best consumed as it is, but you can get a bit more out of the flavor and texture of the bread if you toast it.

Sourdough can be toasted using several different methods but for convenience, the toaster is the way to go!

Typical toasters can easily heat a slice of bread within minutes but they are usually only designed for commercial bread slices and are not tuned for artisanal bread. 

This means that using a sourdough slice in a typical toaster may result in an unevenly toasted bread that may have several cold spots.

Also, as mentioned, sourdough slices may need to be forced into the input slot of a regular toaster, which would ruin its texture. 

This is why we highly recommend that you invest in a toaster that can handle every type of bread – instead of being at the mercy of a run-of-the-mill toaster that can potentially over-dry the bread as it toasts.

Sourdough toasters are designed to effectively and evenly toast a slice of bread so that it is equal in every way and doesn’t take away from the natural texture and mouthfeel of the bread

Don’t worry, we have the best recommendations for sourdough toasters at the end, but before you pick one, please go through our buyer’s guide below for a better purchase experience:

Buyer’s Guide

This guide is designed to help you choose the best toaster for all your sourdough needs!

The great thing about our recommendations is that we have included multi-purpose toasters that can be used for all types of bread, instead of just a few! 

Here is what you need to look out for:

Slot Width

Bakery toasters or specialized toasters can toast all types of bread. They are designed with a larger input slot to accommodate the size of sourdough and other artisanal bread products. 

These slots can be either 10″ x 1.5″ or more. Of course, wider doesn’t equate to better here! 

The general idea is to fit any wide slice of bread or baking product like bagels or waffles without them moving around or tilting to one side.

This is why we recommend that you purchase a toaster that has a slot width of around 10” x 1.5” or less.

Most toasters of this size are also designed to have an elongated body so that the appliance can fit in 2-4 slices at a time

We recommend that you assess your needs before choosing either a 2 or 4-slice toaster with a wider input slot. 

Another point to keep in mind is that having a larger toaster may be beneficial for you in some cases. For example, a one-time investment in a 4-slice toaster may provide extra utility, especially when you have friends and family over. 

Also, having the option to toast multiple slices at a time means that you can make 2 sandwiches in a 4-slice toaster rather than just one sandwich at a time with the typical one-slot option. 

These are small details that can make a huge difference in your everyday experience!

Toasting Options And Features

Most wide toasters have built-in features or settings where you can adjust the toasting time and the toast shade of the bread.

In most cases, a medium toast is more than enough for any sourdough bread but some may enjoy a deeper and crispier toast.

If you are the type that enjoys more control over how their bread toasts then we suggest that you look into the customizable toasters that come with multiple toast settings

Please note that these toasters are made for a variety of bread products so you may not want to toast sourdough at the highest setting as it will easily burn or char. 

Also, always refer to the instruction manual included in the packaging of the toaster for the best experience. Each power setting is different so it’s best to follow the manufacturer’s indications for the best results. 

Finally, some toasters also offer intelligent controls and a small LED display that shows the countdown timer. If you find waiting around the toaster to be cumbersome then these additional features might be useful to you! 

The 9 Best Toasters For Sourdough Bread

Now all that is left is for you to pick a toaster! Here are our recommendations:

RankProductBest Feature
1.LyriFine Toaster for Artisan Sourdough BreadsLarge multi-purpose toaster designed for sourdough bread and more! 
2.Elite Gourmet by Maxi-Matic Toaster6 toast settings. Perfect for heating sourdough slices just the way you like them. 
3.GE Stainless Steel ToasterStainless steel toaster with extra-wide slots.  
4.Oster Long Slot 4-Slice ToasterFit 4 slices at the same time – great toaster for all types of bread products.
5.Elite Gourmet Long Slot ToasterMultifunction large toaster. Excellent for toasting sourdough slices.   
6. Chefman 2-Slice Pop-Up Stainless Steel ToasterPopup stainless steel toaster designed with 7 shade settings.  
7. Oster 2 Slice Multipurpose ToasterCompact, personal, and an excellent choice for a small serving of beautifully toasted sourdough bread.
8.DyBaxa Stainless Steel Toaster with 2 Slice Long SlotsLarge stainless-steel body, extra-wide slots – capable of toasting all kinds of artisanal bread with ease.   
9.Cuisinart Bakery Artisan Bread ToasterThe best in its class! Dual extra-wide slots – the easy choice for sourdough bread lovers.    

1. LyriFine 2 Slot Toaster for Artisan Sourdough Breads

Check Current Price on Amazon

Slot Dimension: (10″ x 1.5″)

The LyriFine toaster has 2 long input slots that can easily fit any type of artisanal bread with ease.

The toaster is designed to quickly heat or deeply toast any type of bread within a minute.

Perhaps the best thing about this appliance is that it is also equipped with a mini-LED screen.

The screen shows the remaining toasting time which can come in handy when you want to multitask in the kitchen and not stand around the toaster to see if the bread has toasted as per your specifications. 

It is easy to clean and maintain and also features a warming rack which will be perfect for refrigerated sourdough bread! 

2. Elite Gourmet by Maxi-Matic Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon

Product dimension: (14.68″ x 7.13″ x 7.68″)

This is a simple toaster that is built with modern kitchens in mind.

The Maxi-Matic toaster is fitted with extra-long and wide slots that can fit in any sourdough slice.

The appliance is geared towards easy usage and can quickly warm up and toast not just sourdough but any artisanal bread!

3. GE Stainless Steel Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon

Slot Dimension: (1.38″ x 5.50″)

Made using a stainless-steel body, the GE Toaster is perfect for accurately toasting any type of bread. 

What makes it perfect for sourdough bread is that it comes with a very precise toasting or “shade” option.

Just turn the dial to how you want to toast the slice and pull the lever down! 

The best thing about this toaster is that it also has a dedicated bagel preset that can help you toast not just bagel but an equally wide slice of sourdough bread as well. 

4. Oster Long Slot 4-Slice Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon

Product Dimension: (6.5″ x 16″ x 7.5″)

If quantity is your main concern, then this 4-slice toaster will fit all your sandwich needs.

Living up to its name, the Oster Long toaster features a 4-slice slot that can fit in any width of bread

It is excellent for quickly heating multiple slices of sourdough and since it also comes with multiple heating presets, you can effectively toast frozen or fresh bread with a press of a button. 

5. Elite Gourmet Long Slot Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon

Product Dimension: (15.5″ x 6.5″ x 7.25″)

Not only is this toaster highly efficient but it is also extremely easy on the eyes!

It’s designed with a polished white body and can easily fit up to 4 slices of bread at a time

This option is excellent for people who want to toast not just regular bread but sourdough slices as well.

Fit in two sourdough slices in one slot and 2 regular bread slices on the other and toast as per the desired setting using the precise temperature knob. 

6. Chefman 2-Slice Pop-Up Stainless Steel Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon

Product Dimension: (11.62″ x 7.82″ x 8.74″)

We simply love the design of this toaster. It’s not overbearing and can easily fit in on any countertop with ease. 

The elongated design of the toaster and its wide input slot allows users to effortlessly fit in any type of sourdough bread

Whether you’re toasting fresh or slightly stale bread, with precise temperature controls and toasting presets, you can rest assured that you will have the best-toasted bread every time.

7. Oster 2 Slice Multipurpose Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon

Product Dimension: (11.7″ x 6.9″ x 7.3″)

Looking for a more personal appliance? Then the Oster 2 Slice toaster is the way to go.

This toaster is designed to replace your old, bulky and outdated toaster in every way.

It can easily fit in two large and wide slices of sourdough bread along with any other type of artisanal bread.

It is equipped with multiple heating and toasting presets that you can rely on without worrying about over-toasting the bread.

It has a smaller footprint than other larger toasters and yet, it is perfect for the job of toasting large slices with ease.

8. DyBaxa Stainless Steel Toaster with 2 Slice Long Slots

Check Current Price on Amazon

Slot Dimension: (10″ x 1.5″)

This toaster has a futuristic look and is designed with both function and style in mind.

The DyBaxa toaster is fitted with two wide input slots and an extremely intuitive user interface with a combination of soft-touch buttons and a tactile knob. 

It is easy to clean thanks to its removable crumb rack. Plus, since the entire product is made using high-quality materials, you don’t have to worry about wear and tear for at least a couple of years! 

9. Cuisinart Bakery Artisan Bread Toaster

Check Current Price on Amazon

Slot Dimension: (10″ x 1. 5″)

The Cuisinart bakery toaster is the best choice for any type of bread lover.

This toaster features two long and wide input slots that can fit in not just sourdough but any type of bread without you needing to force it from the top. 

Generating 1500W of power, this toaster is more than enough to get you started on delicious sourdough bread sandwiches within minutes.

The toaster has a unique and simple unibody design with a clever and convenient power slider that you can conveniently use to adjust the power of the toaster.

Up Next: 11 Best Frozen Chicken Breast Brands

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *