Best 4-Slice Toaster Ovens Of 2023

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

Toaster ovens are incredibly useful and versatile. They can do anything from making toast to pizza to any dish of your choosing. We love these because you can often use them in place of an oven for some things and they are versatile enough to work for simple duties like making toast as well. 

We prefer 4-slice toaster ovens for a traditional size. This gives you plenty of space for making a variety of things and will reliably hold 4 normal slices of bread so you can toast them all at once for whatever your toast needs might be. 

What is the best 4-slice toaster oven? Ultimately, the best toaster oven toasts consistently and evenly. You want to be sure your oven can handle basic functions: toasting, baking, and preferably broiling. Control options, advanced functions, size, and a pleasant design are a matter of preference.

In this guide, we will share with you the best 4-slice toasters on the market. We’ve worked hard to find the very best options out there and we’ve narrowed it down to the top three! 

We hope you’re ready for this. Let’s take a look at the three best 4-slice toaster ovens out there today!

How to Pick Out a Toaster Oven

As you look at the options, here are some simple tips that just might help you make a final decision in the end. 


You will find that toaster ovens can have a broad range of prices.

Look for something that will work for your budget and don’t over-extend it. You can find budget-friendly options that are quality and you can find premium options that are quality as well.


If you’re going to get a toaster oven, you might as well get one that has plenty of features and functions.

Basic functions to look for include toasting, broiling, and baking capabilities, but fancier models may have multiple levels and heat options, as well as specific settings like ‘bagel’.

Check for various control options, as well, such as timers, so you know what capabilities you will have.

You will most likely want to use the oven for more than just toast at some point, although some of the specific settings are a matter of preference. Whether you’re preparing breakfast or a snack, you deserve a few options!

Size and Shape

The size and the look of your toaster oven won’t affect how powerful it is or how well it performs, but you’ll want to pay some attention to this anyway.

Toaster ovens rest on your counter, so if space is an issue, opt for a more compact model. While design is purely a matter of taste, and has no bearing on how good your oven is, it could be the tie-breaking factor between two good choices.

The 3 Best 4-Slice Toaster Ovens

In the following section, you will find our top picks for the 3 best 4-slice toaster ovens:

RankProductKey Features
1.Black & Decker 4-Slice Toaster OvenNatural convection, rack + pan
2.Breville Smart Countertop OvenHeats quickly, 8 functions
3.Hamilton Beach Toaster OvenRoll-top door, easy-clean

We have detailed reviews of each below, too, so you know just what each one has to offer! So keep reading for more and happy toasting!

1. Black & Decker 4-Slice Toaster Oven

Check Current Price on Amazon

Our top pick starts us off with a class-act brand that always seems to have quality options for good prices.

This is no exception to those expectations. This 4-slice toaster oven has specific toast settings with a timer so you can choose your level of toasting for those purposes. 

It also has natural convection modes that are pretty cool. You can set the temperature and use this is as a small oven as well. It can be set from 200 to 450 degrees and includes options for function like warm, broil, bake, and toast. 

You get plenty of options in a sleek and modern design that simply won’t steer you wrong! 


  • Plenty of capabilities
  • Includes oven temperature options
  • A knob specific to toasting
  • Sleek and modern design
  • Durable stainless steel materials


  • There is no on/off button so you have to force it off when you finish.
  • The outside of the toaster gets hot to the touch.

2. Breville Smart Countertop Oven

Check Current Price on Amazon

This is a premium model that comes at a premium price but it really is worth the money if you can swing it. This is a smart 4-slice toaster oven that has a lot of really great features. It has digital controls in addition to dial or turn-knobs. 

There is a single turn-knob that allows you to choose from 8 functions: bagel, toast, pizza, reheat, roast, broil, bake, or even cookies. Then you can adjust the time or the oven temperature on the digital screen. 


  • Smart oven design
  • Multiple functions
  • Digital screen


  • Doesn’t always toast evenly on the toast setting.

3. Hamilton Beach Easy-Reach Toaster Oven

Check Current Price on Amazon

Let’s wrap this up with a fun design that offers a quality toaster oven for you as well.

This option from Hamilton Beach has a unique roll-top door so you don’t have to worry about working around a hot door when you open it up. 

This holds 4 slices of toast and has other basic functions as well. It’s a simple model so you set the temperature and the timer and the machine takes it from there. There’s even a crumb tray so that cleaning up is super easy. 


  • Door detaches for cleaning
  • Roll-top door design
  • Time and temperature controls


  • Some of the parts appear and feel cheap when using.

Up Next: 3 Best Retro Toasters

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *