How To Reheat Baked Ziti – The Best Way

Baked ziti is a dish that is best and most easily prepared in large quantities, meaning that you very well may end up with leftovers. Fortunately, baked ziti is relatively easy to reheat and tends to retain its quality, provided that it is reheated using the proper measures. 

So how do you reheat baked ziti? The best methods for reheating baked ziti are in the oven and in the microwave. If you are reheating individual portions, the microwave will work just fine. If you prefer crispier ziti or are reheating an entire dish, then the oven is your best choice. The time it takes to reheat baked ziti depends on whether you are reheating it from frozen or after it has thawed.

Read on to find out how to reheat baked ziti from frozen or thawed and in the microwave or the oven, always ensuring that it is just as delicious reheated as it was when fresh-baked. We will also address common questions that arise when reheating baked ziti or other pasta dishes. 

What Is Baked Ziti?

Before we get started, let’s review what exactly baked ziti is. Baked ziti, as its name suggests, is a baked pasta dish that contains pasta (duh), some type of tomato sauce, usually meat, and always cheese.

The noodle used is ideally ziti, which is shaped in a thin, round tube. If you can’t find ziti, you can also use rigatoni (which has the same shape but is a bit larger) or penne (which is also a small, tube-shaped noodle, though cut on a diagonal instead of straight). 

When it comes to sauce, a classic marinara is sauce is the most traditional choice. The meats used vary from Italian sausage to ground beef or pork, though the meat can be omitted or substituted with vegetables to make a vegetarian version.

Much like in lasagna, you will need three kinds of cheese: ricotta, parmesan, and mozzarella. 

Thawing and Reheating Baked Ziti

First, a word on thawing frozen baked ziti.

Though you can cook baked ziti from frozen, you may want to thaw it to minimize cooking time. To thaw baked ziti that has been frozen, transfer from the freezer to the fridge and let thaw for at least 24 hours, though smaller portions should be able to thaw overnight. When in doubt, put your frozen baked ziti in the fridge a day before you plan on eating it. 

If you’ve stored your baked ziti in the refrigerator, you have two options when it comes to reheating: in the microwave or in the oven.

Though both are viable options, reheating in the microwave is undeniably quicker, while reheating in the oven will ensure that the cheese doesn’t get rubbery. 

Reheating Baked Ziti in the Microwave

If you’re only reheating a small portion of baked ziti, the quickest and most convenient way is in the microwave.

• To reheat refrigerated baked ziti in the microwave: Simply place the baked ziti into a microwave-safe dish and pour a few drops of water or milk over it. Cover with microwave-safe plastic wrap and cook for 1 ½ minute on medium power, then check to see if it is warm. If it is still not warm all the way through, continue to heat in 15-second increments, which helps to ensure that the pasta doesn’t overcook and dry out. 
• To reheat frozen baked ziti in the microwave: Cover and heat in the microwave on high heat for 5 minutes. As with the microwaving method listed above, check on your baked ziti after this time is up, and if it hasn’t heated fully through, continue to heat in small increments of time, ideally 15 seconds, until it is fully heated. 

Reheating Baked Ziti in the Oven

If you have to reheat an entire baked ziti, or at least a large portion, your best bet is in the oven.

• To reheat refrigerated baked ziti in the oven: Cover with aluminum foil and bake at 350 degrees F for 30-40 minutes.
• To reheat frozen baked ziti in the oven: Cover with aluminum foil and bake at 350 degrees F for 1 hour.

To know that it is fully reheated, the sauce should be bubbling, and if at this point the cheese on top hasn’t browned, uncover and bake or broil for a few minutes until it does.

A quick note on reheating baked ziti that has been frozen in a glass or Pyrex dish. If glass experiences extreme temperature changes too quickly, it runs the risk of breaking. To avoid this, let your frozen baked ziti set out until the dish comes to room temperature. 

Other Ways to Reheat Baked Ziti

If for some reason you cannot reheat your baked ziti in the microwave or the oven, you do have another option.

If you don’t have access to a conventional oven, baked ziti can be reheated in a toaster oven. You will want to make sure that your baked ziti has been thawed if frozen.

To reheat, follow the same instructions that you would with a conventional oven (covered at 350 degrees F for 30-40 minutes), though cooking time may vary depending on the size and potency of your toaster oven. 

How to Store Baked Ziti

Once baked ziti has been cooked, it will last about 3-5 days in the refrigerator, ensuring you a few nights of delicious leftover baked ziti.

If you’d like to start making your baked ziti in advance to get ahead of dinner preparation, you can prepare each individual component (sauce, meat, pasta) and assemble. 

To do so: Cover and place your assembled (not yet) baked ziti in the refrigerator. Baked ziti that has been assembled but not yet baked will last up to 24 hours in the fridge, after which it should be baked at 400 degrees F for 20 minutes covered and 15-20 minutes uncovered. 

Can You Freeze Baked Ziti?

Baked ziti will last up to 3 months in the freezer, allowing you to enjoy this rich and comforting pasta dish long after you bake it. Additionally, similar to the method described above, you can prepare baked ziti up to the baking step and freeze if you know you won’t be eating it right away. 

To do so, simply cook each individual component and assemble your pasta dish. If your baked ziti has not yet been baked, it will last in the freezer for up to a month.

To reheat, just thaw and then bake at 400 degrees F for 20 minutes covered and 15-20 minutes uncovered. 

Related Questions

Can baked ziti be eaten cold?

If you have already cooked your baked ziti and have leftovers sitting in the refrigerator, you can certainly eat it cold, we won’t judge. It cannot be eaten cold if it has not yet been baked.

Additionally, it is not recommended that you eat it cold if it has been frozen and thawed, as it could be soggy if it has incurred any freezer burn. 

How do you avoid drying out baked pasta when reheating?

Pasta is undoubtedly best when eaten fresh, but there are some steps that you can take to ensure that it doesn’t dry out when reheating.

First off, keeping your pasta covered as long as possible throughout the reheating process helps to trap in the moisture and keep the pasta from drying out. Pasta that has been frozen may run an even higher risk of drying out, so be sure not to overheat it. 

When reheating in the microwave, add a few drops of moisture (water or milk) to keep the noodles hydrated.

Alternatively, you could add a little bit of pasta sauce if you have any on hand. Again, even when reheating in the microwave, keep your pasta covered, and be alert for any crackling sounds, which may mean that your pasta is overcooking.  

How do you improve leftover baked pasta that has been reheated?

Leftover pasta may not be as good as fresh baked, but there are a few things that you can do to make it as delicious as possible. As we noted above, if you have any extra sauce lying around, add a few tablespoons to keep the noodles from getting dry. 

Additionally, sprinkling some mozzarella cheese on top before reheating is a great way to get a creamy and delicious texture. This is especially recommended if reheating in the oven, as the top layer of cheese will get crispy and golden brown. 

Up Next: Can You Freeze Green Bean Casserole?