|

Ham Shanks Vs Ham Hocks – What’s The Difference?

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

Ham shanks and hocks are highly underrated cuts of pork that are packed with flavor. They are both inexpensive, readily available, and are mostly already smoked, so they are ready to go in the pot!

Both make for great additions in various delicious recipes and are central for many types of broths. But when it comes to these collagen-laden parts, what is the difference? 

So, what’s the difference between ham shanks and ham hocks? Ham hocks come from the lowest portion of the animal’s leg, near the ankle, while the ham shank is located just under the shoulder or hip of the animal. Both pieces contain lots of collagen and very little meat. 

Read below to learn more about ham hocks and ham shanks, how they taste, how to use them, and the best way to make broths using each! 

Ham Shanks

As mentioned, ham shanks are located and cut from just under the shoulder and hip of the animal. Shanks mostly consist of collagen, fat, and a little meat but some varieties can be meatier too.

Shanks are excellent and indispensable when it comes to making delicious stocks and broths for soups, sauces, and other umami-rich dishes. 

The collagen and fat are wrapped around a bone and the entire section can be thrown in whole. What makes shanks so great is that they can be used in many ways. 

For example, in Chinese cuisine, shanks can be marinated in soy sauce, garlic, and other herbs and then deep-fried in a large wok to caramelize and release the flavor of the meat. 

The meat is then further processed by marinating it again in the sauce overnight to break down the collagen and then the entire piece is finally steamed. The result is a ham shank that is completely tender, juicy, and deliciously seasoned. 

Shanks also make for great additions in stocks. As they are usually pre-smoked, they add quite a lot of complex flavors and a bit of salt to the mixture. You can find unsmoked variants in the market too!

Disappointingly, many people look the other way when it comes to shanks as it doesn’t offer the normal texture that is commonly associated with meat. 

But if made the right way, it can be something of a revelation for many! 

Ask your local butcher to give you a meatier shank if you wish to broil, braise, or roast it. We’ll also attach a few great recipes below to help extract the most out of their flavor. 

Texture

As stated, shanks contain lots of collagen, fat, and a bit of meat so the first thing that you would notice is a thick white layer surrounding a large mass with a bone at the center. 

The thick white layer is the collagen which has a soft and spongy texture. It can be quite chewy, especially if it is not cooked thoroughly but when cooked, the collagen will easily break apart and will be very tender. 

Under the collagen is a layer of fat that is mixed with a bit of collagen and meat. When boiled or steamed, the fat will liquefy and seep through the layers and lend a very balanced and fatty flavor to the exterior.

Since the meat is mixed with fat and collagen it will have a soft and gelatinous texture. A great way to determine a properly cooked and tender shank is to twist and lift the bone at the center.

The bone should come off easily and cleanly and you should be able to break open the collagen layer using a fork. 

Spicy And Tender Ham Shanks Recipe

To make the most succulent ham shanks you will need:

For Marinade:

  • 1 tbsp dried oregano
  • 1-2 tsp pink sea salt
  • 2 tsp paprika dash
  • A sprinkle of cumin powder
  • 1tsp fresh cumin seeds
  • 4 cinnamon sticks
  • 3 bay leaves
  • 1 jalapeno, diced with seeds
  • 4 cloves of garlic, diced
  • Pepper to taste
  • 2 tbsp olive oil

For Cooking

  • 2-3 ham shanks
  • Half a bottle of red wine
  • 1-2 cups homemade or prepackaged bone broth
  • Drizzle of oil
  • 1 onion, thick slices
  • 4-5 carrots, thickly sliced

Instructions 

  1. Marinate the ham shanks using all the ingredients mentioned above and leave for about 2-3 hours or overnight for more flavor. 
  2. Heat a heavy-bottomed pot and add a bit of oil. Sear the ham shanks on each side so that they get a beautiful brown and lightly charred color on the collagen or meat. 
  3. Add the cut onions and carrots into the pot along with all the marinade spices (reuse the ones in the marinade container). Cook until onions are slightly translucent. 
  4. Deglaze the pot using the red wine (pour in red wine). Boil and reduce to half and then add in the stock. 
  5. Preheat oven to 320°F and place the pot in, uncovered, for about 3 hours. Garnish with fresh mint leaves and the liquified juices from the pot and enjoy! 

Ham Hocks

Ham hocks, also fondly called “pork knuckles” are similarly boney and collagen-laden pieces that have little to no meat on them. 

They are located closest to the foot of the animal and are predominately used for stocks or soups.

Even though this piece of the animal doesn’t have much meat on it, it still lends a subtly gamey and fatty flavor. Their flavor is even more prominent when the hocks are smoked!

You can find these at any supermarket or butcher shop. They are relatively inexpensive, especially compared to meatier shanks and even one hock is enough to flavor dishes like spicy red kidney beans or sauce stocks.

For a more concentrated flavor, we recommend braising (boiling) 2-3 hocks over 3-4 hours

We’ll get to how to use them in a bit. Let’s first discuss the texture of ham hocks!

Texture

Ham hocks are almost rectangular and have a bone at the center. The bone is surrounded by collagen and a bit of fat. 

Visually, they look like big rectangular chicken drumette pieces except with the meat being at the center and the bone protruding from each end. 

Texturally, ham hocks have a rough exterior and can be considered to be hard as the collagen located here is much denser than what you would find on the shank. Cooked hocks will reduce in size and can become very tender too.

Cooking them for substantially longer will result in the bone separating from the collagen and fat. This typically tends to happen when making broths. 

Also, while there is little to no meat on the bones, you may still be able to scrape some muscle fibers from the bone or under the collagen. The meat is very tender, juicy, and has a softer, gelatin-like texture

Typically, the bone and collagen are discarded and the meat is added back to the pot at the end – you can also choose to keep everything in! 

Ham Hock Recipe

While you can also BBQ ham hocks, they are best utilized when they are braised to extract their flavor. 

Ingredients

  • A large pot for boiling water
  • 3-4 onions, sliced
  • 3-4 carrots, sliced
  • Celery, sliced
  • Salt to taste
  • Pepper to taste
  • Ginger 3-4 sticks
  • Garlic 3-4 cloves, crushed
  • Peppercorns 1 tsp
  • Star anise 2 pieces
  • Cardamom 3-4 pieces
  • Cloves 2-3 pieces
  • Cinnamon sticks – 2 pieces
  • Bay leaves. 1-2 leaves
  • Coriander seeds 1 tsp

Instructions 

  1. Clean the ham hocks properly so that they don’t have any dirt or unwanted residue on them. 
  2. Bring a large pot filled halfway with water to boil. Add all the ingredients to the pot and let it simmer at medium heat for up to 3-4 hours. 
  3. Filter the broth into a cheesecloth and squeeze the ball over the broth so that all the flavors are fully extracted and added back to the pot. Discard the spices and herbs. 
  4. Reduce the broth as required and store in a jar or use immediately.  
  5. You can store the broth in an airtight jar in the fridge at 40°F for 3-4 days. You can also freeze the broth and store it in the freezer at 0°F for up to 6 months! 

Related Questions

Ham shanks and hocks have a lot of culinary use despite their lack of meat.

Even though both these pieces are largely made of collagen, fat, and bone, they are packed with flavor and can add a unique taste to any dish!

Here are a few more related questions on the subject!

Can ham shanks substitute ham hocks?

Yes. Ham hocks and shanks share a similar texture and flavor. They are also made up of the same type of collagen and bone mixture, so you can use both of them interchangeably

However, shanks offer a bit more culinary use than hocks so you will have to consider its use in the recipe – but for making stocks, both of them can replace each other.

Why are shank and hock broths sticky and have a gelatinous texture when frozen? 

Shanks and hocks consist of collagen and fat. When simmered in water, the heat breaks down the collagen and releases the fat which gets distributed throughout the mixture, giving it a shiny and sticky texture

When frozen or refrigerated, the molecules clump up together and form a gelatin-like texture which can be liquified again by adding the gelatin to a hot pan with a bit of water. 

Up Next: Black Beans Vs Kidney Beans – What’s The Difference?

One Comment

  1. Thank you for the great recipes and especially for additions and you explained the “why” of there can be added small differences.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *