3 Best Potato Mashers for Non-Stick Pans

*This post may contain affiliate links. Please see my disclosure to learn more.

How do you mash your potatoes? Do you use a specialty potato masher or do you have another tool or method that you typically go to? We have found that you really can’t beat a potato masher tool when it comes to homemade mashed potatoes. 

These tools are perfect for mashing potatoes to just the right consistency. You can get them nice and creamy or you can keep them just slightly chunky. If your kitchen doesn’t have a potato masher it really needs one! 

What is the best potato masher for non-stick pans? When you’re working with a non-stick pan, we recommend using silicone as it won’t scratch your non-stick surface up. You also want a potato masher that is durable enough to withstand mashing lots of potatoes. Something flimsy won’t work well for mashing potatoes, and you could get frustrated with the process. 

In this guide, we will share with you our top 3 picks for potato mashers, with complete reviews. It can be challenging to narrow down the options but we managed to come up with the very best so you don’t have to spend your time digging and searching! 

Keep reading to see the 3 best potato mashers for non-stick pans! 

The Best Potato Mashers for Non-Stick Pans Reviewed

These reviews will be shared in ranking order, starting with our top pick. Each review also contains a list of pros and cons about the potato masher. 

Let’s take a look! 

RankPotato MasherBest Features
1.Zulay Premium Silicone-Coated Potato MasherSilicone coated, durable, fun color options
2.Calphalon Nylon Potato Masher UtensilHeat resistant up to 400 degrees F
3.Farberware Heat-Resistant Nylon MasherEasy to use, unique and versatile design

1. Zulay Premium Silicone-Coated Potato Masher

Check Current Price on Amazon

This option from Zulay is fun and colorful! They do have a stainless steel option as well but we recommend using a silicone-coated option for a non-stick pan.

These come in fun colors like red, blue, and yellow. 

This is a top-rated potato masher and the silicone coating is thick and durable. It has a sturdy handle and frame so it won’t break when you put it to the test.

This is easy to clean. Your food won’t stick to it or cling. You can even toss it in the dishwasher if you prefer. 

Zulay offers a no-hassle satisfaction guarantee so if you aren’t happy, you aren’t stuck with something you hate. This is made with premium materials and comfort in mind. 


  • Silicone-coated
  • Sturdy and durable
  • Colorful options to choose from
  • Satisfaction guarantee


  • It would be nice if the silicone covered more of the metal to protect the whole pan

2. Calphalon Nylon Potato Masher Utensil

Check Current Price on Amazon

Our premium pick comes from Calphalon. We know this brand to be premium in quality and price.

This potato masher is a bit on the pricy side for what it is but it is a really great option and it is also highly-rated. Even at a pricy level, it’s still affordable. 

This is made with high-quality materials that will last over time. All of their products have a lifetime warranty so you know they are built to last.

This is made with nylon and it will not scratch your non-stick items! 

This masher is dishwasher-safe and it is also heat resistant up to 400 degrees so you can use it even when your dishes are piping hot! It’s created with a rounded design so you can easily mash anywhere in your pan. 


  • Dishwasher-safe
  • Heavy-duty nylon materials
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Premium brand


  • The nylon is fairly flexible and sometimes leaves chunks

3. Farberware 5211438 Heat-Resistant Nylon Masher

Check Current Price on Amazon

Finally, we have a masher from Farberware. This is another nylon masher that will be gentle on your non-stick cookware. This is a unique style.

It’s made to be able to mash meat, potatoes, sauces, and more. Many people love these tools for browning meat but they are exceptional for mashing potatoes too. 

This is made with a sturdy handle. It’s often referred to as a mix and mash tool because it’s designed to do both in a single step. This is durable and heat-resistant as well. The handle is comfortable to work with. 

It’s easy to use and you can toss it in the dishwasher when you’re finished! 


  • Friendly for non-stick pans
  • Unique and versatile design
  • Easy to use
  • Durable materials
  • Lifetime warranty


  • The star shape can be challenging to clean as things tend to stick to it

Related Questions

We hope you find this guide to the best potato mashers for silicone pans to be a valuable resource for finding your new kitchen tool!

We invite you to review our question and answer section for some additional details. 

What’s a Good Potato Masher Alternative?

If you need an option until your new potato masher comes in, you can try a few different things. If you have a food mill or ricer, those are great. You can also use a food mixer to get your potatoes creamy. Alternatively, a heavy mug or even a fork will do. 

Can You Mash Potatoes With a Whisk?

If you’ve already slightly mashed your potatoes, you might be able to finish them with a whisk. This may also work as a mixer attachment. If you’re just whisking by hand, this probably won’t work that well. 

Up Next: How To Fry Leftover Mashed Potatoes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *